Tuesday, 21 February 2012

  • The Controversial Boundaries Between Friendship and Emotional Infidelity

    Before recent events, I had only witnessed one occurrence of "emotional cheating" in my life and that was several years ago when my aunt was carrying on what my mom called an "emotional affair" with her kids' little league coach and her former classmate. Before then, I never even knew such an affair existed. I had always thought that cheating was purely physical. Boy, was I proven wrong.

    Recently, I introduced two of my best friends. One, a single man in his early twenties, with wishes to start a life in the military - the other a young woman in her early twenties with wishes to move to a bigger city and pursue her dream of art. The catch to this: she was in a relationship with a soldier who was stationed 2,000 miles away.

    Over the months after I introduced them, they became significantly closer, even going so far as to exclude me from group outings, movie dates, lunch dates, and whatever else. When I got excluded, they began doing more intimate things: seeing movies as a couple, going to lunch as a couple, having dinner with each others' families, and even going so far as to spend the night at one another's house. She began to confide in him about her relationship and her overprotective boyfriend, but who wouldn't be if their girlfriend was cavorting around town with a man he didn't know, who was basically serving as a replacement for the man who was actually her boyfriend?

    A few days after New Year, my friend expressed extremely strong feelings for the aforementioned young woman. He basically stated that he felt sorry for her and that he was scared that she wouldn't be able to handle being single once she and her boyfriend broke up and that he might as well step up and be the one "she stays up all night and talks to on the phone because she would have no one else to do it." I couldn't believe my friend was being so cavalier about it, especially after he had seen her behavior when her boyfriend was all the way across the country.

    Over the summer, my guy friend will be going on a mission trip to Alabama for three months and immediately after, he is leaving to enroll in the coast guard, which leads me to believe that she will replace him with someone else, as she did her previous boyfriend. Obviously, she needs someone tangible, who can be there for and with her at all times and he won't be able to be that soon.

    I found this article online and most of the characteristics (with the exception of sex) listed matched their "friendship" perfectly:

    What are some of the red lights that detect whether you are an emotional cheater?

    • You keep aspects of your intimate life for your “friend” and do not share them with your partner.
    • Your friendship shifts from platonic to romantic and you feel less connected to your partner.
    • You think about your friend most of the time and you fantasize about him or her even when you are making love with your partner.
    • You feel recognized, appreciated, even loved by your “friend” so you do not feel the need to connect to your partner. You feel a distance between you and your partner.
    • You withhold and “cut off” valuable aspects of who you are, particularly your intimate self and your intimate life from your partner. You stop having sex with your partner.
    • You discuss the things you don’t like about your spouse or your married life with your friend and not with your spouse.
    • You tell your “friend” more about what goes on regarding your workday and your work life than you do with your partner.
    • You feel as if your “friend” has your heart.
    • You are dishonest with your spouse about the extent of the friendship and feelings with and for your “friend.”
    • You would be embarrassed if your partner read the e-mails, notes, or eavesdropped on a conversation, or saw the way you interacted in person with your “friend.”
    • When you are with your “friend” your body language communicates that your feelings are stronger than friendship.
    • There is sexual tension and you can discuss it openly with your “friend.”

    The girl confessed on a social networking site that feelings did accumulate while she was still in her previous relationship, so I'm not just completely speculating here. 

    So, what do you think is worse, or are they the same: Physical or emotional affairs?

    I feel as if the two are bad in their own ways. With physical affairs, you're sharing something as intimate as sex with someone other than your partner. But with emotional affairs, you're sharing something even more intimate than sex: your mind, your heart, etc. with someone other than your partner. This is a battle even for me, because I have no idea which would be worse: knowing that my fiance had sex with someone else or knowing that my partner was emotionally and romantically connected to someone other than me.

Comments (22)

  • lewk@xanga

    They're both pretty fucking vile.

  • srsly__x@xanga

    Both are horrible. But I think I would much rather be physically cheated on than emotionally. However, both would end any relationshit of mine.

  • desecrationofthepicke@xanga
  • Kazydai@mancouch

    This is like asking, "What's worse: having your left leg cut off, or your right?" Both suck. I guess I can see that one type would be harder for someone to deal with, though.

  • RyanTerrence@xanga

    If you can easily have feelings for another like that, then your relationship is fake and not meant to be.

  • xhalesx@revelife

    Both are cheating. And cheating is a horrible thing to even consider, emotional AND physical!


    I just can't even imagine being the one to do that to the one I say I love. I know what it's like to be emotionally cheated on. It is not a good feeling at all. And I would never wish it on even my worst enemy. My boyfriend has also been cheated on multiple times. We discussed this even before we started dating and cheating is a deal breaker for both of us. We know from experience how it feels and we truly love each other and would never do something like that to each other.
  • Nous_Apeiron@xanga

    I think the worst would be both physical and emotional cheating.  The completeness of their disregard for your relationship with them would be devastating.

  • raspberryjade@xanga

    "You would be embarrassed if your partner read the e-mails,
    notes, or eavesdropped on a conversation, or saw the way you interacted
    in person with your “friend.”"

    - That's a big one. because I feel like some people are just oblivious as to how far they're taking their "friendship" but when you think about it, if you're embarrassed if your partner sees how it is then that should be an indicator something is wrong!!!

  • Christy412@xanga

    I think you are judging them harshly and it is really not any of your business. Period.

  • dynamicstars@xanga

    another warning sign is when you see your "friend" with a person of the opposite sex and feel jealous. that's what it took for me to realize that my "friendship" was not exactly platonic. i backed off and now we're not as close as were used to be, but i felt more comfortable knowing that i was not being unfaithful to my then boyfriend.

  • Sanuramon@xanga

    My ex had an emotional affair. It kills. And I have found it more difficult to get over because it's easy to forever deny an emotional affair because "nothing happened," although in reality a whole lot of *something* happened even if it wasn't actual sex. And when the cheater denies, you can never really talk about it and work through it. It just remains as a wall between you. 

  • lewk@xanga

    @Sanuramon@xanga - Same. It was pretty soul crushing.

  • under_the_carpet@xanga

    emotional definitely. Honestly if I *knew* that physical stuff is just physical I would not
    even be angry. My fear would be that the other one is liked better than
    me. I personally don't necessarily associate sex with love, but it depends
    on that  I guess...if I felt like my partner did I'd be hurt. The thing with cheating is that it hurts when you hear yor partner went that far with someone behind your back . On the other hand, for many people sex is THE decicive reason to even stay in a relationship, so it's hard to be sure and  to not be insecure and to forgive.I'd wonder if I'm good in bed an attractive maybe and what I fail to give, but personally I don't think I'd even get together with someone like this.

    I remember when I had my first bf I realized that I trusted some girl a lot more than him and just wanted to be/spent time with her, so I broke up. It's just more honest. I think if you start feeling detached from your partner or they feel like you are growing apart you should work on it, and if that doesn't or wouldn't help break up immediately. I think a realtionship makes no sense without trust.

  • galadrial@xanga

    Hmmm....Like so many areas, I suspect this has shades of many colors to it.

    1. Emotional affairs don't usually take root in stable relationships. They happen when emotional and intellectual needs are not being met...usually as the result of long term frustrations.

    2. I believe emotional affairs are more dangerous in a way, than the physical sort, precisely because they are not taken as "seriously". They are not to many people's minds "actual cheating". But it is intimacy that makes them affairs...not sex.

    3. You turn to someone else when you've been closed out, or shut down. No one says "shut up", but when you are punished often enough for what you say, you retreat to silence. The emotional partner is not as laden with landmines---and the sheer relief of being able to open up at all is truly heady.

    4. I don't "blame" anyone for them....particularly not the spouses who have no idea they are happening.  We have this habit of making our own hell...and get angry when it happens.  Women marry men for "financial stability", then get upset that there is no romance. Men marry women other men envy...then get angry when they are not something else they need.  Emotional partners can Spackle over minor flaws...giving the sensation of a more complete relationship. The Primary remains intact...but the intellectual and emotional needs can also be met. But not by one person....and therein lies the trap.

  • jeezshoua@xanga

    Emotional affair is definitely harder to accept (in my case, anyways).  It hurts more when the man you're supposedly love til death-do-us-part won't even look at you or find you sexually attractive anymore.  He seems like a completely different person altogether.  Speaking from experience.  

  • Xbeautifully_broken_downX@xanga

    Both are destructive. Monogamy is hard, though, and it comes with it's own sets of rules and challenges.

  • ZombieMom_Speaks@xanga

    The list doesn't just sound like an emotional fling, though. All of those factors are present in any cheating situation. This sounds a lot like convenience; the 'friend' is there and available, the boyfriend isn't - this doesn't justify anyone's actions, but she seems to be really needy. If I were her boyfriend, I'd always feel as if the time I spent with her after my deployment would be largely based upon having to check up on her. She's already shown that she can't be trusted. 


    Unfortunately there isn't anything you can do that won't make things worse.

    @RyanTerrence@xanga - It doesn't mean the relationship is 'fake'. Often relationships start out strong and with the best of intentions, but a few years down the line they both find that things have changed and no one is getting their needs met. The relationship was never 'fake' (they were in love and committed to one another) but it is different and they have to figure out where to go with it. 
  • BlehhItsTu@xanga

    Both hurts. Better to end a relationship if even a bit of emotion/sexual desire stirs strongly enough to initiate such things with another person.

  • anonymous
  • NinaRose_85@xanga

    I would think emotional cheating would be harder to handle....  With physical, I would think people make more mistakes.  As in, they were with someone, too much to drink, etc. etc., but they still love you and want to make it work.  They aren't cutting you out.  But I would think trying to deal with someone cutting you off emotionally would be a lot harder to handle than knowing someone made the mistake of having sex with someone who wasn't me, but they still love me.  Granted, if it was a continuing physical thing... I don't know how I would react.  

  • kim899

    powerful kumar,(powerfulkumar@yahoo.com)I wanted to inform you of something. Okay, I currently live with my ex-boyfriend's mom because her husband and my ex moved to South Carolina. Well, you performed the love retrieval spell for me. I work 3rd shift and when I came home this morning, my ex's truck
    was in the driveway. I just got up and we chatted for a few minutes and he told me that he was moving back home. I just wanted to share this good news with you. Thanks. Your friend Kim

  • superGchik@xanga

    cheating is cheating, doesn't matter what form it is.

  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

  • jesshinson
    • From: jesshinson
    • Name: J. Hinson
    • Location:
    • About Me: I'm 20-years-old and age is not but a number when it comes to my wisdom. Writing is one of the few things I genuinely love in life.
    Stats: This Week All Time
    Posts: 0 10
    Views: 0 25132
    Comments: 0 226
    View all posts by jesshinson

Who recommended?