Saturday, 17 September 2011

  • A Noticeable Difference in How Women Treat You When You're Thin

    Just to start out and clarify, I currently have almost no experience in the world of dating and relationships at the age of twenty-two.  There were many issues I had growing up that may have contributed to this, but now, even though I've still never actually had a girlfriend before, things have been going a lot better for me lately.  I've been feeling a lot better about myself and confident in approaching women than I did in high school and most of college, and I think it might not be too much longer before it happens for me.  I get much more positive feedback from girls than I used to, and though there are many things I have done differently from my days of being really bad with girls, the most noticeable difference in me is probably that I am a lot thinner.

    From elementary school all the way through my first couple of years of college, I was really overweight.  I used to try to make myself feel better by telling myself things like, "I'm not really that big" or "it's not bad enough to really be a problem," but honestly in retrospect, I was definitely much bigger than was healthy.  I was certainly well enough above average to be considered obese.  Going back and looking at old pictures of me from those days makes me realize how bad it really was. 

    However, it certainly also makes me extremely proud of how much I have changed since then.  Right around my junior year of college was when I made a conscious decision that I really wanted to be thin, and since then I've come such a long way.

    Ever since losing all that weight, I have definitely seen a noticeable difference in the responses I get from girls.  When I'm out walking across campus and pass by them, I get glances and smiles a lot more often than I used to.  At parties, they seem interested in talking to me a lot more often, and they definitely laugh at my jokes a lot more.  Back when I was overweight, if there was ever a girl I liked, I was always asking the question in my head, "Is she really interested in me, or is she just being nice?" but now it's much easier to tell the difference, since I now have much more experience in seeing how a girl acts who might actually be interested.

    Part of me is proud of having changed so much in the past couple of years, but another part of me is still stuck in the mindset I used to have.  Even though I'm a lot better looking now than I used to be, the negative reactions I used to get caused me to become shy and awkward around girls, and I guess that's still kind of left over.  It is still very hard for me to ask a girl for a date, even though it's not nearly as hard as it used to be.

    I have been told by several good friends of mine, including girls and gay guys, that naturally I am actually very good looking.  I honestly don't know how to judge my own appearance objectively, but given the responses I have gotten since becoming thin, I have considered the idea that it is possible.  Also, girls tell me once in a while straight to my face that I am "cute" or even "adorable." 

    Because of all this, I think its fair to say I know what it is like to live the life of both a very unattractive person and of an attractive person.  The way people treat you in general is extremely different, and often when I experience the difference, I think back to the days of being fat and how hard of a life it really was compared to now.

    Being overweight honestly sucks, and even though I am not anymore, I can truly sympathize with anyone who struggles with dating because of it.  Whenever a really overweight guy sees someone who gets his heart pounding, he just doesn't have that same hope of actually getting a chance with her as an average- to good-looking guy.  Also, a most unfortunate truth for overweight guys is that women who average- to good-looking guys think are beautiful are also beautiful to them

    When you're so much less attractive than the average to good-looking guy, it can sometimes really hurt to know that you just don't have the same chances with her as a guy in better shape, and the only way you know how to make yourself feel better is with more food.  It's like being addicted to heroin and being constantly caught in an endless cycle of being lonely and not knowing what to do.

    I think it's really sad how really overweight people are treated differently by those who catch their eye than they would be if they were in better shape, now that I have truly experienced the difference.  I am extremely glad I decided that I wanted badly enough to be thin to go through all the discomfort it takes to get there, but I know there are still so many severely overweight people out there who won't ever have that breakthrough like I did and will continue to be stuck in the same situation I used to struggle with for the rest of their lives. 

    Rather than looking down on them and saying I wish they would just quit being lazy and do what it takes to lose all the weight, I want to take a second to say I understand your pain, and I sympathize.

    Have you ever been through a similar experience?

Comments (50)

  • QuantumStorm@xanga

    First impressions matter. Although guys put a good amount of emphasis on looks when it comes to sexual attraction, women can be just as affected. Never trust a woman who says she only cares about what's on the inside. 

  • Chibi_Son_Gokou@xanga

    Unless you're Quasimodo, being ugly doesn't matter much to women, as you will see that women date ugly men all the time.  

  • TiredSoVeryTired@xanga

    Yep, I was 50 pounds heavier than I am now and it is true, people treat overweight people so poorly.  It is very sad.  I like that you are taking the attitude that you are.  So many who lose weight became judgmental.  Good luck to you!!  :)  I am sure you will continue to gain confidence.  

  • shimmers
    I've never had a weight issue but I've had friends go through this. I think it's rude when people insult someone to be supposedly fat though they've got issues of their own they should be worrying about and shouldn't be choosy. I definitely see how awful bigger people are treated and ruled out because of their weight. Glad you brought this up.
  • Guteman91

    Let me start off with I'm glad to hear you lost all that weight, that your feeling better about yourself, and congratulations sir!

    I would argue though that people, especially women, aren't necessarily treating you differently just because of your weight loss. From losing all that weight you obviously gained a much more positive and confident view of yourself, which it turn makes you more attractive. In other words, your change in personality and attitude towards life is what has made you more appealing.

    As a guy your actually lucky because women place far more emphasis and importance upon a man's personality rather than his looks. Whereas for a woman, men are inherently shallow, and it's much more difficult for us to look past her appearances.

    On topic of food addiction though, I hate it when people discount it. An addictive personality is a serious issue no matter what outlet it ends up going through. And either way it's sad and painful to watch. There's a vast difference between someone who is lazy and someone who has a legitimate problem. For instance my father consumes huge quantities of the food and is stagnant for most of his day, it's no surprise that he's overweight. Whereas my mother on the other hand, gained quite a bit over the years because she was clinically depressed. She got help, medication, and lost all the weight. Lazy v.s. legitimate issue.

    Have I been through a similar experience? Again I've never been overweight but I have had poor body image issues over the years thanks to the aforementioned parents above. My appearance and anything/everything that I did or didn't do was picked at. Needless to say I didn't have a positive view of myself and I actually thought of myself as overweight for awhile (I was closer to a twig).

    Either way this is me being over-analytical and endlessly rambling. Who cares?! Your healthy and happy! Congrats again!

  • xx_x_beautifully_broken_x_xx@xanga

    I sympathize with them too. But unfortunately, it's in our human nature: no matter how much we try to deny it, appearance does matter. (For first impressions anyway, which are very important).
    :(

  • Roam_The_Shadows08@xanga

    I'm pretty much living that right now. I've been overweight for most of my life and have been treated accordingly. People, not just women, treat overweight people much differently than the thinner people. Doesn't matter the gender. For some people, it's not a matter of being able to lose the weight. Some people are genetically predisposed to being overweight. People are treated different and get acted toward in a different manner than those are thinner. This is speaking from experience.

  • HollowTendencies@xanga

    I lost a lot of weight my senior year in high school and I am a lot skinnier now than I was back in my high school freshman days. Like, 45 pounds skinnier. And I am still EXTREMELY shy, because I was constantly ridiculed for seven years, constantly, HORRIBLY ridiculed and bullied. People try to talk to me a lot more than they did when I was fat and I still have this awful low self-esteem problem, so they usually just think I'm stuck up and I hate that. Anyway, I disagree with your point of view about sympathizing. I was lazy, I ate too much, and I was letting my emotions get to me, this is why I was fat, and I took action to fix it. I'm not saying that's every overweight person's problem, but most of the time it is, and they can fix it, if they would just TRY.

  • P0RCELA1N_D0LL@xanga

    why are some overweight people of both genders aren't attracted to others, who are also overweight, but they are attracted thin or average weight people...so thin people, who aren't attracted to overweight, can't be considered shallow, since some overweight people aren't even attracted to similar to their own weight people either. some are, but I was just saying that if the people that think thin or attractive people are shallow because they are attracted to good looking people, but so are they, so it would make them a hypocrite and some overweight people aren't exempt from being shallow.


    I've been on the other end of the weight spectrum where I was thin or considered too skinny by some and they didn't find me attractive, so they criticized me. attraction is subjective, so some people found me attractive the way that I am. I'm usually attracted to thin and athletic guys. it is an aesthetic appeal and partly sexual, too, because I don't think overweight people have that much stamina in bed, just saying.

  • substitutesoul@xanga

    what if you're a chubby chaser

  • FuntimeswithGoldie@xanga

    Men treat thinner women differently than heavier ones too, I think it's an across the board gender truth (typically). One of the reasons is due to confidence because even I have noticed that I am much more confident when I am thinner. I am also much more outgoing and my moods are better because I have energy from being more active.
    I also think that we can all say that having sex with more in-shape folks is a better experience so  when it comes to dating, in shape in sexy.

  • HerParaph@xanga


    @Chibi_Son_Gokou@xanga - i frown on comments like this. Women do care, and so do men. we've been socialized to understand what is attractive, which usually coincides with what seems to look like the most ideal mate (ideal is based on resources and fertility). 
  • Ethonox@xanga

    shoulda stayed chubby cause i know a lot of girls that are chubby chasers

  • TheFashionableEconomist@xanga
  • valeriebeth04@xanga

    I know how it is. Fat girls get treated like crap!! I'm overweight and I get ignored by guys. I signed up on an online dating site, but I'm afraid to send a message to certian guys because of my weight. There aren't many guys who like big girls.


    I know I need to lose the weight. I'm trying, but its hard! I know I need to try harder. I'd rather just be single than end up with someone who will criticize my weight.

  • enoughtodiefor@xanga

    I wonder how much of this is actually girls treating you differently and how much of it is just in your head.

  • just_like_air@xanga

    i totally agree with you, i used to be be overweight, and people in general, not just guys (im a girl btw lol) just kind of were nice to me when they wanted something. I lost quite a lot of weight (around 10kg) and people were becoming more drawn to me - but that may have been because i was alot happier, idk- now ive put on a bit of weight, im not overweight, but im noticeably heavier... people dont take as much notice of me. guys dont try to start as many conversations with me.

    its kind of sad, but it kinda shows that first impressions matter =(
  • PARTYdontPOUT@xanga

    Maybe after you lost all of the weight you became more confident in yourself? Girls love confident guys and that may have been a part of the more attention that you got. 

  • anonymous
  • lttlegel@lovelyish

    Forgive me, but I'm going to be blatantly honest. One of the commenters here said a first impression is important... I agree. & the impression that an overweight person gives is that they are lazy slobs who eat too much and refuse to work out. I KNOW that is not the case and I'm not saying it is with everyone. But in general, that's the stigma that comes with being overweight... and in my experience, many times that is true.

    Being overweight is unhealthy, there are so many diseases and conditions linked to it... and most times when someone thin sees someone overweight they say or think "I don't know how they let themselves get like that!" Because thin people care how they look and care about their health.

    I also agree with the person who said your attitude changed your perception because you were happier and it gave your more confidence.

    Here's a little tip [although I know it may be easier said than done] if you don't like something about yourself, change it!

  • oneLBcloser@xanga

    So... when you were fat you were only attracted to thin girls, and felt bad that they were only attracted to thin men. Now that you're a thin man, are you going to defy vanity and date fat girls? Doubtful because the real moral of the whole story is that fat people are unattractive. Sure some people are into that kinda thing, but there's plenty of out-of-the-norm fetishes, so don't respond to me with something about chubby chasers. The only people who date fat people are other fat people or otherwise unattractive people because of lack of option. It sucks, its sad, it's vain. That's the world we live in.

  • The_Aftershock_3650@xanga

    I'm even in slightly better shape than last year (my freshman year of college) and already girls give me better responses. I wasn't even overweight, just average... and now I'm a little leaner and the change is dramatic. I'm working on getting a six pack and a ripped body (a choice I made mid summer), so we'll have to see what happens once I reach that goal, bahaha.

    It's all evolutionary, I think.

  • pnklace@xanga

    Being overweight is unhealthy. Though some people have certain biological differences that cause them to be overweight, generally it is brought on by excess eating and most of the time combined with little to no exercise in that person's daily life.

    It is how you live your life. Other people might not see that your lifestyle can suit theirs, therefore both are incompatible. You might not see that but the other person does. You aren't being rejected because of only your physical factor, though it might seem like you are. If that was true then there wouldn't be so many ugly guys with beautiful women. It is generally known that overweight people do not have healthy lifestyles, and therefore will be unattractive to average to slim women.

    On another note, I am not attracted to very bulky guys who spend too much time on their appearance and not enough on more intellectual pursuits.

  • Rose_Hikari@xanga

    I grew up quite shy and quiet. I would have crushes on boys who never, ever liked me back... in retrospect, I suppose I was average looking, but I was just so awkward and insecure that it's not surprising no boys liked me. Boys only started paying attention to me once I was well into high school. Still, I didn't even get my first kiss or boyfriend until my senior year. He was a friend first, which is probably why he asked me out--he's the only boy who actually got to know me (:

    Anyway, to the OP, girls may treat you differently because of your physical appearance, but I'm guessing your confidence level went up once you lost weight. Maybe that's why girls treat you differently. I know once I started to break out of my shell boys paid more attention to me. No one really likes an insecure person.

  • lov3lybones@xanga

    my ex boyfriend gained 40 pounds over the two years that we were dating and i still think he is so handsome :)

  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

Who recommended?