Wednesday, 14 September 2011

  • Real Relationships and Television

    The other day someone asked me a very good question

    "Do you think what we saw on tv as children defines how we view relationship when we got older? If so, will it be the same for our children?" 

    And I honestly had to think about it. It could be a very definite possibility, over the years I have watched countless tv shows that portray this 'storybook romance.' The kind that every little girl and maybe boy would dream of. But why?

    What makes us wish for something that seems so perfect, so unattainable. Why do we sit and wait for that so called prince charming, hoping that nothing will ever go wrong?

    Is it because tv makes us think that things are supposed to be that way? Like, sadly enough my love life has taken an odd turn for a soap opera, but is that because I search for drama like a heat seeking missile?

    Maybe we try to live our relationships out like they are tv shows, because we have never seen a functional relationship around us. I believe that maybe the relationships around us affect how ours will turn out. Maybe our parents teach us without even trying. 

    I know the whole nature vs nurture argument is still alive, but maybe it could also be the environment that we are surrounded by. If you grow up in a dysfunctional home, maybe you wont have good relationships because you don't know what stability really is.

    At least that's just what I believe.

     

    What do you believe we base our relationships off? Do you think that tv has anything to do with it?

Comments (13)

  • shatteredmoonbeams@xanga

    Im not sure about Disney movies, tv, rom-coms, etc. affecting my EXPECTATIONS of relationships, but it may have affected my standards. Aladdin was (and still is) my favorite Disney movie, and perhaps the message of "love who you love no matter their social class/race/appearance/etc" affected me. Really the only major requirement I have for a boyfriend is that he love me for me, not who he wants me to be. Ive had boyfriends who try to change me-thats the one thing I cant put up with under any circumstances.


    i guess Im saying I need my own Aladdin-like story. =)
  • enoughtodiefor@xanga

    I wouldn't say defines. Influences, definitely, I know of tangible ways that movies, music, and other electronic media influenced my relationships. But I would like to think that I consciously define them.

  • GettingClosertoFine@xanga

    Oh Jesus--and nowadays, all the shows are sperm competitions or love triangles

    Crap, let's hope TV doesn't define relationships for our kids.

  • HollowTendencies@xanga

    I don't think TV is what caused us to expect romance from our partners. I think before TV was even invented, girls (and maybe guys) still wanted that type of romance and their "prince charming". I guess you might also say that it could have been books that influenced how we view relationships, and then it just evolved into TV (I love how I just argued my own point), but then it makes you wonder where people even got these ideas. I mean, it had to start somewhere. Do you understand what I'm saying? I'm saying someone had to have these desires about having a perfect mate before they even read/wrote a book or watched/made a movie about it. Where did THOSE desires come from? WHY GOD WHY?! Idk.

  • Guteman91

    Our society and culture will ingrain some sort of fantasy notion in our minds at a young age of what our life "should" be. I agree that T.V., especially Disney, has a significant impact on how we view relationships. Television and other electronic entertainment devices are being used more and more as babysitters rather than the actual parents teaching their children any moral codes, values, or lessons. So if you won't raise your kids, MTV and Disney will do it for you. And you have no one to blame but yourself for their crappy behavior when they grow up.

    In the end both genders place ridiculous and unattainable standards for the other (or whichever they prefer) to meet.

    And yes these romantic notions have always been around (although they constantly change with each generation), just from different sources. Prior to T.V. it was radio, and prior to that it was books, before that there were plays and the theater (when most people were illiterate I mean), and then there's good ole' fashioned oral storytelling.

    In the end if your going to live your life based upon a T.V. show or character be ready for life to give you a wake up call and subsequent bitch slap.

  • SadeeLunaRose@xanga

    you have an awesome point, and when i think about it i really agree with you@HollowTendencies@xanga - 

  • testyman666@xanga

    @HollowTendencies@xanga - yup 100%  it existed before TV and will forever

  • lilblucherrygrl@xanga

    I think most things influence us whether we realize or not. As I've gotten older I've learned that nothing lasts forever. Instead of seeing it as depressing I see it as realistic now. People live much longer now-in-days so to expect to be with/love only one person in your entire lifetime is a fairy tale.

  • superGchik@xanga

    i think when we start relationships we do but once we get into them and realize that it's nothing like it's portrayed on tv and the movies, we change our minds.  it's definitely so innocent to think that way.  we shouldn't be tainted by love the first time.

  • Lyrical_L@xanga

    There is really no telling what influences our love life or our expectations.

    My parents are a little dysfunctional, so they were not role models for me or my relationships.

    And television placed a lot on the drama, so I have to say not so much.

    My expectations were influenced by my necessities. I knew I would need someone who could handle my depression. My expectations for myself also influenced what I expected from my SO.

    So, I really don't know.

  • kor_girl@xanga

    I think when we were kids, tv programs were much "milder" in its effect to influence us in how we view relationships. I didn't watch teenage moms complain about going to prom while trying to find a babysitter for the night. I didn't want Kate plus 8, screaming at her family and her kids on reality tv. I watched Disney Movies about Beauty and the Beast, Little Mermaid and Bambi.


    Granted, Disney love stories often had impossible feats to overcome and live happily ever after. They never really explain what happens AFTER they get married, or ride into the sunset. And at that age, I doubt any one of us questioned the ending of a movie or a story. "But mom, what happened AFTER they lived happily ever after? Did they have kids? Did they go on a trip?" See?


    I worry about my kids watching Spongbob, Dora the Explore and eventually MTV shows too early in their childhood. It's much more toxic then the stuff I was allowed to watch or even seeked out at that age. I wonder why...are we needing more radical sh!t to make an impact in our desensitized way of thinking or does it just keep getting worse on top? *sigh* I do worry.

  • anonymous
  • fantaiesiesombre@xanga

    This certainly is a possibility. I knew ever since I was a little girl that I wanted my own Prince Charming. I knew I wanted him to be tall, pale, with dark hair, bright eyes, and a bright smile. I always identified with Snow White, Belle, and Ariel in a few ways back then, as well, and wanted my future husband to be a mixture of their very own princes. (And yes, at three years old, I thought about stuff like this) I've certainly kissed a ton of frogs, and got beaten up by a few of those toads, but never in my dreams did I think I'd be in the relationship that I'm in now. It's like God wrote my own fairy tale, and I love it.

    So, to answer your question, I think it depends on the person and the material they are given. I think it influenced my wanted romantic life, in a way, but I know I didn't want any second away from this person - which each of the princesses I mentioned before had to deal with. I know I didn't want any heartache - which is a very innocent thought. I also didn't want to deal with death - and still don't. The point is, if you surround yourself as a young one with positive ideals about things like marriage and family, then in the future you will want nothing but positivity. I know the kids nowadays watching those silly shows about drama this and who slept with who behind who's back just advocates selfish behavior, and real relationships aren't about being selfish.
    I really think society needs to go back to the old ideals, where we treated each other with kindness, we helped others, and we certainly didn't gossip about you know who doing you know what.
  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

  • SadeeLunaRose@xanga
    • From: SadeeLunaRose@xanga
    • Name: SadeeLunaRose
    • Location:
    • About Me: I love writing, reading, talking or anything that has to do with those things. I write a lot about love and relationships, and usually am trying my hand a poetry. Being a hopeless romantic helps for a lot of things, but someday may be my ultimate downfall. I am rather laid back when it comes to things, but i can be serious when the time comes for it. I am half english on my fathers side, but I was raised in the US, Minnesota is my home state, but soon I am moving to Montana. I love white guys, love love love them.. I guess thats just my english nature.. I dont regret things, life is too short for that, and I dont do drama. Its just not me. I love life, and I love my friends and family, i couldnt ask for anything more. So if you want to get to know me, dont be afraid to send me a message, I love have intellectual and intelligent convos. :) Well thats me
    Stats: This Week All Time
    Posts: 0 5
    Views: 0 12169
    Comments: 0 104
    View all posts by SadeeLunaRose@xanga

Who recommended?