Tuesday, 28 December 2010

  • The One That Got Away: My Story


    He is the most amazing man I have ever known. He set my standards high for what I should look for in a mate. He was my bestfriend, my protector, my shoulder to cry on, my adventure buddy, and a father figure in many ways. He saved me from being the dumb girl I was.

      I never realized how I felt about him back then.
    Maybe it was my extreme comfortableness I felt around him or the fact that I had known him most of my life. We did everything together. We gave each other rides when our cars broke down. We took road trips together, we cooked dinner together, fell asleep on the phone....and so on. When I needed a place to hide out, he would let me stay over as many nights as I needed. I would cook and clean for him and his roommates. A great group of guys I'd like to add! The most wonderful thing about our relationship was he never once tried to hook-up with me. We kissed, but that was simply it. He respected me, that's more than I can say for most guys I've known.

      Our friendship was a beautiful thing. Apparently, back then, everyone thought we would end up together...I had no idea. To me he was just my goofy pal, aside from his god-like looks of course. He was the most genuine person I knew.

      I knew he had a crush on me. We did flirt here and there, he would compliment me a lot, and he cared about my well-being. Any thought that crossed my mind of advancing our relationship to a new level was quickly crushed by my fear of losing my amazing guy-friend. Having him there in my life was so important to me.

      Eventually he started dating a new girl. He was a bit older than me and many girls liked him. I knew he still had feelings for me though. That's when I started to feel my feelings for him stronger than ever, but I kept my mouth shut. He had a new girlfriend. I liked her. She was nice, pretty, talented, smart, funny, and most importantly she loved him. I was happy for them. She even became my good friend. I pushed my feelings aside for a long time.

     One day him and his girlfriend started having some issues. I had become pretty close with her at this time, so I knew both sides of their story. I tried to talk with him and encourage him to understand her more and not to be so angry. He then spilled all his feelings he had for me. My mouth dropped and for the first time in my life I was speechless. Ask anyone who knows me, I am NEVER short on words! When I finally was able to collect myself, I numbly spoke, and told him he needed to go to his girlfriend. She loved him after-all and he would always be my bestfriend. At that same time my heart was shouting at me to take him. To keep him for myself and to never look back.

     Less than a year later they were married. Somewhere down the line she must have suspected his feelings for me, because she stopped being my friend and made him write me a detailed letter explaining how we couldn't be friends anymore. I don't think anything ever hurt me so bad. This letter hurt me more than my father passing away. You see, I never acted on my feelings for him and when he told me his I told him to go to her. I was being a good friend on both ends. I was being respectful. All I really wanted was friendship, from both of them. I just ended up lonely. I was so angry that I did the right thing and still ended up being hurt.

     Now he still writes me short e-mails from time to time. When I see him he will tell me I look pretty and ask me how life is, as if nothing has changed. It really bothers me that he does this. He left our friendship behind, doing as his wife asked, and decided to take the good-husband road, so why not just stick to it?

     I cringe whenever I meet his gaze, yet my heart beats faster all at the same time. I am no longer in-love with him, but I realize being together would have been the only way to keep him as a bestfriend. I have fallen in love with someone else since then. Someone I love more than anything else in the world, but that's another story.

      All I ever wanted was my bestfriend. I guess you can't win them all. I've finally come to terms with it, but damn it.....would he stop looking at me like that? And would people stop telling me he has talked about leaving his wife and trying to be with me? And would my mind stop going back to the time I could have kept him for my own?

      It's difficult. I love a good man now, but I think back to that moment so many years ago where I could have just had him. If I would have embraced our mutual love for each other that day, I know I would have avoided so much I've been through up to this point in my life. My life would have been beautifully simple. A good husband, nice big house, maybe some babies. I don't have regrets about whom I love now or how difficult things have been for me, but sometimes I just think...what if?

     I know some of you are probably thinking, well stupid girl, avoid him, don't see him, don't talk to him! The only problem with that is, we live in the same area, have all the same friends, I'm friends with his whole family, we attend the same church, same weddings, same parties, and so on. I am not going to drop my whole social life to avoid him and his wife. It's just something I have to live with.

      Do you ever think what would have been different if you would have chosen love over respect or pride? Do you ever think "what if?" Do you have one that got away?

Comments (81)

  • Poet251@xanga

    I actually enjoy'd reading these. I feel where you coming from, and I don't think you was stupid for doing what you thought was right. I have did somethings like that. What If? runs thru my mind a lot over a certain person,who is still in my life. I had to come to terms to let him know how I feel. Took a lot in me. Either be friends and keep it as that, or let the feelings you have for them eat at you when you know the feel the same. It's crazy, it was like a battle with myself for almost four years before I actually told him how I felt, but with his help hinting.. Sometime's I don't think I did the right thing and sometimes I do. Like 1/2 n 1/2. Embrace the new man in your life. You always going to have them feelings and it seem he still may have his for you. She jealous, she prob knew how he felt along time ago and just wanted you closer to her to keep eyes on you. Stuff happens. She suffering if it was talk about leaving her for you. I believe these the longest comment I have made on another one blog and I could keep going on and on.. God Bless! :)

  • Ethonox@xanga
  • MissMaritimes@xanga

    great story. im sorry it ended this way for you.

  • UnconventionalButterfly@xanga

    Great story hun, i'm so sorry this happened to you. I never had one that got away because I've never had a relationship that lasted over 3 months (I know,its sad lol!). You did the right thing in the end, never regret that and be happy with your new man :)

  • wolvenchic@xanga

    Well, all I can say, is don't get so caught up in what could have happened.. that you loose what is in front of you now. I know your saying your over it, but I can tell its not completely if your thinking about the happy life you could have had popping out his babies. I do understand where your comming from, but that same perspective has caused an unnamed hurt to many of my friends over the years because they keep thinking "what if". He was the one who made the decision to move on to someone new, even if it was to come back to you, for you to confirm he had no romantic love with you. If he meant his feeling for you, he would have left her and made himself a real option, as opposed to keeping his options open with a giflfriend who loved him dearly lingering in the background. He put you in a bad position.

  • eatdrinkandbemaryy@xanga
  • lil_KyungMin@xanga

    @UnconventionalButterfly@xanga - me too! 3 months was my longest.


    If you can be happy that you did the right thing I wouldn't be so upset about your decision. You love someone else now. You're moving on already. It's a big step already. You can't let your past haunt you like that. You'll only end up bitter and unsatisfied with life. Believe me, I've been there. It's the worst time of your life when you're stuck thinking of the what ifs. Get out of that thinking now! Or else you'll go through the worse depression of your life. Life is too short to be thinking of whatifs.


    Think ahead now. Think of your future and learn from your past to not let go of those things you love. Your departure from him was a lesson to keep whats dear to you at heart and never take them for granted. So for that person you love now, don't let your whatifs cloud your capacity to love him.

  • ashley_wth@xanga

    I'm sorry it ended this way for you, but at the same time, congrats on pushing forward in your life and finding someone you love with your whole heart. You've managed to move on and push forward, which is something not all who have been in similar positions could say about themselves.

  • SpOnTaNeOuS_sPiTbAlL@xanga

    i don't have any "one[s] that got away" I am with the one.. and I figure you know when its THE one when you don't think or care about any other one[s].
    sorry it didn't work out,
    but past is past and if he left you go so easily, is he really a true friend?

  • sunflowersforlove@xanga

    That is so sad :( That happened to me, too. He didn't get married, but when he came back from Afghanistan he got into a relationship and his girlfriend made him stop talking to me because she thought we were too close. I was in a relationship when that happened and I have been for two years and I am completely in love with my boyfriend and he's my best friend, but I still miss my old friend and how easy it was to talk to each other. I try to push him out of my mind because I have such an amazing boyfriend now that I don't want to do the whole what if thing. Sometimes I still do. 

  • Sammysosa76@xanga

    Good story, Stay strong. I am glad you found a great man now.

  • mademoiselle_rachelxx@xanga

    This was well-written. I've never really had that problem, as I've always gone for it. Even when I was scared shitless. And it never really worked out well, except once, but I don't wonder now.

  • Kazydai@mancouch

    Why is it that people KNOW what they want, SEE what they want right in front of them, and can easily HAVE what they want, and yet do nothing to make it happen?? This could've easily been a "one that almost got away story".

  • anonymous

    this website is very good, you can go and see it




    http://www.shoes4world.com/

  • Beb3Lika@xanga

    this is such a bittersweet story.. loved reading it though.  it definitely sucks to have "what ifs"; these thoughts tend to hold us back a lot, but i'm glad you found another great man out of your act of kindness and respect.  i wish you the best. 

  • oOo_itsJuJu@xanga

    This is so sad. I have two guys in my life right now that would absolutely give up their worlds for me if they had to, yet I have no feelings for them. Part of me says, "They're good guys, and they ADORE you. Why not give them a chance?" Another part of me says, "Don't lead them on and pretend there's something there when there isn't. You can't FORCE chemistry and you absolutely cannot force love."

    It's tough. And it's even harder to try to rewind your life and redo things, especially when marriage and relationships are involved. Maybe just try to be patient and see what life has in store for you. =)

  • eatingabook

    Oh man, I know how you feel :( well in my case, it was an ex that I became best friends with, and he understood me perfectly. He was the perfect friend, after we realized we couldn't date. And eventually he got a new girlfriend who I also became friends with, like you. After a short period of being a good, respectful friend to both of them, she also asked him to write me a letter telling me we couldn't be friends and couldn't talk anymore. I was heartbroken, although not because I wanted to be with him, I just didn't want to lose my best friend. In my case eventually their relationship didn't work out and I got my friend back, although now we are not as close. Maybe because I realize his opinion of me could be swayed by a girl he was never really all that in love with... I dunno. But I'm so sorry you had to go through that too :( now it just seems so confusing for you. Maybe talk to him about it and tell him that he has made his bed and has to lie in it; he is married and he made his choice, he can't keep talking about the past and what could have been. If you want, let him know you will always be his friend, but that he can't keep telling you he should have left her for you, etc, since it is too hard on your emotions.

  • CluelessHeart@xanga

    Wow, it sucks that you didn't even get to be with him the way your heart truly desired.  I hope you eventually find your own happiness, forgetting about this awful heartbreak..  

  • dontsang823@xanga

    don't think too much gal

    you had your chance but you just didn't fight for itnow they're married, why not just bless them instead still thinking to get him backeven though he thinks about you, tell him that he's a married mandoing the right thing doesn't mean you will feel good/comfortableanyway... I think friendship is very importantyou three should talk this through, I don't think his wife has right to stop you guys contacting:DC:
  • TheDarkAndMisleadSoul@xanga

    As said before, good story and very well-written. I thought I'd get tired of reading and just close the tab, but I was wrong.. :P


    There was a certain person that kept popping up in my head as I read on and on. I may not be/have been in the same exact situation as you're in, but it's enough to relate. 
    As for your question, well, I'd choose friendship over love. Sometimes I wonder what would've happened if my relationship with that certain person went further. At the same time, however, I didn't want to lose that person and the valuable friendship that already existed.  :\

  • jamoncita@xanga

    i had one guy who i thought of once as the one who got away, but recently ive let it go.  we tend to make things greater in our memories than perhaps they really were, and i'm happy for the guy in my life now.

  • splinter1591@xanga

    like this post.


    im sorry.  (>VV)>
  • callist0@xanga

    This gave me goose pimples.

  • TheCatInTheCradle@xanga

    aw, this is so sad :(. but i really commend you for being such a good friend to both of them, even if you lost out.

  • HollowTendencies@xanga

    I'm in a relationship now. It's going kind of crappy. Another guy has been talking to me, and I'm afraid he's going to be my "what if". :(


    You only live once they say. I guess you just gotta ask yourself what YOU want to do and put everyone else's feelings aside.
  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

Who gave the eProps?

2 eProps from:

0 eProps from: