Sunday, 21 November 2010

  • What is Love, And What Makes it Different From Obsession?

    I stepped off the tube and took the escalators to ground floor level. Musical ads filled the walls on either side of me. "Mamma Mia", "Billy", "Wicked", "True Love Never Dies". 

    True love never dies. 

    What is love and what is obsession? I am led to reflect on that. When someone you love dies, and years later you move on to love someone else, does this mean you no longer love the first person? 

    During WWII, many soldiers were MIA. For years after the war, they were stuck as prisoners in war camps, whilst their wives at home thought they were dead. All that kept these soldiers going was their love for their wife, and their hope of return. Years passed. Five years, then ten. Ten years. One day they finally approached their own doorsteps. It was opened by a man they didn't know; they were greeted by children whose faces they didn't recognize. Was it the wrong home? Surely not, because there she was. As beautiful as ever. Her face was a portrait of horror. Her glass shattered to the floor. 

    Did she ever stop loving him? She thought he was dead. Now she loves another. Can she love both of them the same? Can she now leave her love for her love? 

    Sometimes you love a person who is less than worthy of your love. Months go by. Years go by. You attempt to make it work. You love the other person. You love your children. But suddenly, your love is no longer reciprocated. Your partner may say he does, as he wipes alcohol's sweat off their forehead, touching a cold tissue to the bruise on your eye, but they do not, and you know it. 

    Some stay. Out of "love". Some leave. Out of "love". In spite of love, some may leave. Because of love, some may stay. 

    And sometimes love turns to hurt, which --when not confronted-- breeds bitterness, which leads to hate.

    But has love died? Has it evolved into something else? Would you hate them so, had you not loved them so?

    And when you stay, and suffer, and proclaim "love will demand this sacrifice", is it love or obsession?


    What is love, and what is obsession?

    Can true love die?   

Comments (21)

  • KonFefCount@xanga

    Wow... that's really tough to ponder.... I'm going to have to think about that one for a long time....

  • steph

    I think the difference is that obsession is unhealthy, & it's to the point where everything in the obsessive person's life comes down to their compulsive ideas and/or emotions about the object of their affection. It affects everything in that person's life.


    Someone in love isn't psychologically imbalanced. It's a healthy, positive thing for them, unlike obsession, whereas obsession has a more negative connotation.
  • callist0@xanga

    Nicely said.  I never really knew the difference, and that example you used left me with goosebumps.

  • fairiesmythsdragons@xanga

    I believe that true love never dies. Even though I "hate" my ex-boyfriend, I know that I still actually love him. I wouldn't waste my energy hating him if I didn't. The opposite of love is apathy, not hate.

  • RockstarJuiceNStarburst@xanga

    @fairiesmythsdragons@xanga - Opposite of love is apathy, not hate. First time I've heard that, and I have to agree with you. 

  • P0RCELA1N_D0LL@xanga

    this reminds me of the Castaway movie when she thought tom hanks was dead.


    if it is true love, I think you can always love them even if you're not together. if someone deeply impacted my life, they have a place in my heart and I still have love for the person. I think obsession is more lustful than anything else and can make one act irrationally. love, to me, feels serene and comforting...like everything just feels right and you are in paradise

  • CelestDiggory@xanga

    True love never dies. Some love was never destined to ignite. Some love ignites at the first glance of their eyes and when the sight of the person you truly love comes into view, whether it's been several years or several minutes, the fire will burn. Large and lovely, the fire will burn everlasting.

    Love is the attraction of two, mutually, whereas obsession is a crazy type of attraction, and can be one sided. Although, the first couple of months of a relationship can equate obsession from both parties.

  • sjunca@xanga

    I can say with certainty that I have been obsessed and I have been in love. Let me tell you they are worlds of different!

    When I was obsessed, I made up a relationship with someone just so I wouldn't feel lonely even though he rarely showed interest in me. I was obsessed with the guy so much so that I didn't even know the person I was just pretending that he was everything I was looking for even though I didn't really know much about him. I would hate on any other girls that he would date too. I never got to the point that I would hurt him b/c I'm not that type of person but I was stuck in my head and addicted to something that wasn't real. It's just like people who become attached to someone and hurt them if they want to leave or hurt them if they've left. Obsession is so unhealthy! I was stuck on this guy for 6 years!

    Love is everything. It makes the world go round... literally. I am currently in love with someone. We had a wonderful relationship but had to go our separate ways because we live 1000 miles away from each other. We rarely speak now because it is too hard. I still care for him and wish him the best. Sure I get jealous when I see that a girl comments on something of his on facebook in a sweet tone. But it's odd because I keep hoping that he will get with someone new because then I feel like I can finally move on. I want him to be happy. He always treated me right and we tried to make things work but it was just too difficult. We each had things to deal with on our own.

    Love is selfless and selfish at the same time. Obsession is an addiction and incredibly selfish!

  • TheSecretLifeOfPandas@xanga

    true love cannot die.


    then it wouldn't be true love.
  • HollowTendencies@xanga

    I don't know if it's because I'm tired, but I'm having a really hard time comprehending what you're saying.

  • lauralen@xanga
  • StillNotaPrettyGirl@xanga

    obsession is based on emotion and biology. love transcends chemical reactions.

    and no, "true" love doesn't die. i broke up with my True Love ten years ago.. he's across the country from me now.. we are both with other people now that we love also.. but I do still love him too, and a part of me will until the day that I die.

  • atychiphobiaa9@xanga

    i think true love may be all too vague a term because there's too many possible matters it may be referring to. i think in reality there may even be more than one true love &i think it does last if not physically, it'll still last mentally. i think that ww2 wife had never stopped loving her soldier husband &she still loves her more recent husband just the same. life is changing every second &i think it's just a matter of personal priorities &their choice of responsibilities that trigger their decisions. hm &i think love can include obsession because it's much more than simply obsession but obsession alone cannot be love. x.teeryley

  • MadMarch@xanga

    There are differences between the story of the POW's, the "abusive spouse that causes the angry partner" and obsession. The POW's didn't have an "obsession", they had Schrodinger's Cat. To them, they still had a relationship with their wives, which is a perfectly healthy thing to want to return to. They thought they were returning to their normal lives. The "abusive spouse" thing can be simple hate or feeling like you have to stay for the kids, or martyrdom-I HAVE to stay for the kids/myself/I don't deserve anything else (not that I'm trying to make light of the psychological torture some people go through in abusive relationships, where they're told they aren't good enough/worthy/competent repeatedly).

  • wainn@xanga

    True love can die. After all, nothing lasts forever.

  • aotolife@xanga

    First of all, in response to your statement: "And sometimes love turns to hurt, which --when not confronted-- breeds bitterness, which leads to hate."

    True love will never lead to hurt. The only thing that hurts you is another person's actions and betrayal. Love will never do that to you.

    And regarding the scenario of WWII. My personal opinion is that I don't think those women ever stopped loving their first husband. They moved on to someone else once they were able to, after they got through the pain of losing their husband. But the new husband is loved with a different love. She will never forget her first husband that provided a home for her, gave her children, gave her warmth - but sometimes they move on out of necessity, especially during that time. Many women didn't work and the only way to have a steady income was to be married to a working man.

    We can't really say if they loved the new man more or less and how that could be possible. We can't know for sure until we ourselves are put into that position.

    Rage For Love

  • MeStripped3@xanga

    Almost a year ago, a few months after my boyfriend and I got together, a good friend of mine said to me "he's not in love with you, he's obsessed with you!" I wonder what she woud have to say if she read this... I think my boyfriend is obsessed with me, and in love with me, if that's possible. I love him, and I don't think I'm obsessed with him...

    Does true love die? That depends on your beliefs and such... Does every person have a soul mate? If yes, then no, true love doesn't die. If a person may have more than one "soul mate" in a lifetime, then yes, it can die. I think true love stays impacting a person throughout his or her life.
  • mudkiwi@xanga

    "Never say never."

    "Nothing lasts forever."

    "True love never dies, true love lasts forever."

    Who knows what the heck to believe anymore, I could see it logically (even though it's completely emotional) being argued either way.

    In my personal opinion, though, you only truly give away your whole heart once. I don't like to tamper with the phrase "true love" because the definition of that is different for every person and cannot be described in words.

  • LuckySadness

    This was very beautifully written.

    This makes me want to be a writer.

  • alsigirl@xanga

    The WWII story was not a single incident. It happened any number of times, all with slightly different details. There were cases where service men came home to their wives who had stayed single but there was another child in the house that wasn't his. It all worked out eventually, not to each one's satisfaction but "you can't un-ring a bell." Something held couples together, whether the original ones or the new ones, and there had to be a degree of love in the mix, otherwise why would they have coupled? Many had the wisdom and ability to forgive, a very important ingredient in a loving relationship. The post the other day about the effects of oxytocin probably had a lot to do with it too. I do think a person continues to love another long term even when they separate or one dies. True love has to be the kind that lasts into old age and morphs into the two being as one all through the years with each caring deeply and doing for the other first.

  • forever_sin@xanga
    One of the greatest posts I've ever read.
    Yes,if you are obsessed with someone,you will make up stories between the person and yourself.
    If you are in love,and you know there is limited love,you wish&let go.
  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

Who recommended?