Monday, 27 September 2010
-
But Your Business Is My Business... Right?
Recently, my best friend told me she thinks I'm nuts. Now, this happens often enough that it's not usually worth writing about, but in this case, I actually disagreed with her.
I was telling her about my day at work, and as I spoke, I mindlessly thumbed around on my boyfriend's phone, playing a game. As I played, he got a text from a mutual friend of ours. I read it without showing him first.
She snatched the phone out of my hand, and, after calling me nuts, said, "Your boyfriend's texts are none of your business, psycho."
My response? "Um, actually, you bet your sweet ass they are."
I'm of the belief that there is no such thing as a friend I don't know about. There is no such thing as a conversation that I am not allowed to hear. And there is certainly no such thing as a text that I am not supposed to read. In a serious, long-term, monogamous relationship, there should be no secrets. That's my privilege as his girlfriend, and the person he shares his life with.
Open book, baby, open book.
Because if we really live by the open book principle in relationships, there should be no reason to go through an SO's phone, scour his or her facebook, or break into his or her email. And, if you should stumble upon anything, there should be no issue, because you are a part of an open, trusting, completely honest relationship free from secrets that could devastate your partner should they be discovered.
So if I'm enjoying a game of brickbreaker on my SO's blackberry, and a phone call comes in from a number I don't know, I should not be scared or hesitant to answer the call. It won't be some chickadee he hooked up with at a bar, because that's not how relationships work. And, if it is, I deserve to know, so why not answer?
...Right?
Would you feel uncomfortable reading your SO's text messages? Is there a fine line between SO privileges and prying?
Post a Comment
- Back to datingish's Datingish Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in datingish's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)


Recommend


Comments (120)
If he ain't your son and you're not paying that phone bill - you have no right checking his messages without his consent prior to you doing so. Its an invasion of privacy.
I don't read my SO's text messages only because we understand a certain amount of privacy with each other. Sure, I play with her phone, but I don't go into their texts. And she doesn't go into mine. We define it as a sense of trust and being an open person, I always tell her what's on my mind.
I open my boyfriend's messages but we essentially share a cell right now and he'd rather me check it and read it than accidentally open it mid-game and forget about it. Privacy is privacy, but I really believe if you're gonna marry someone and get serious and be in a serious monogamous relationship, and you're STILL freaking over cell-phone-privacy...well...just not a relationship I'd really want to be in. To each their own, I can understand both sides of the argument. But I live with my boyfriend. He listens to me burp, knows all of my secrets and my friends, puts up with me night and day around that time of the month..why would I care about cell phone privacy? After being together with so long, it's all taken into perspective, I think, and looks kinda silly.
That's just me though ^_^ Like I said, some people are very privacy driven.
it's only a problem if there is something to hide. for example, myself, i have nothing to hide and would have no problem with my bf going through my texts / pics / calls. i would have a problem with, say, my mom going through them, though, because there are (obviously) things i think she would disapprove of lol ;] but as with all things in a serious monogamous relationship i think you have to talk about these things before hand. obviously if your bf doesn't have a problem w/you playing a game on his phone he has nothing to hide, but tbh i don't think it was any of your friend's business whether you looked through his phone / texts.
that was really long lol. sorry.Even if there are no secrets between the two of you (which I don't really agree with, I think a certain amount of privacy can be healthy), you may be compromising the privacy of the person sending a text. They may be confiding something in your boyfriend that they are not ready for you or anyone else to know.
@astudyinemerald@xanga - was going to say exactly that. you should be open with your boyfriend, but all of your boyfriend's friends shouldn't have to be open with you, too.
Not every business of mine is your business in despite of the fact that we're in a serious, long-term, monogamous relationship.
I'd like to think that any self-respected boyfriend/girlfriend should never give themselves the privilege to check his/her SO's text messages or answer phone calls. Of course, unless the SO asks you to do it.
ive been dating my boyfriend for over 6 years now and i still dont think i would ever read his text messages. obviously in some situations (for example if i was using his phone and a text from our really good mutual friend came up, i might read it) it can be alright, but in general what is the point of reading his texts? like someone already mentioned just because you want to know everything about your boyfriend and his conversations does not mean his friends are ok with that. i respect the fact that my boyfriends friends may be texting him about something they might not necessarily want me to know about and i am fine with that. because i trust my boyfriend i am 100% sure he is not going to be texting or calling girls he hooked up with at a club and i trust that if a girl did come on to him he would have no problem rejecting her without me stepping in. i think the question is do you trust your boyfriend?
I don't check up on my husbands phone but it's not off limits to me.
Uhhh. To a certain extent... I agree.
I agree that you should be able to go through his phone if you want... but I don't agree that you should. If I'm on the SO's phone and something pops up, I tell him what it is... but don't open it.
I don't necessarily think that there should be secrets in long term relationships... but I understand that everyone needs a little privacy... and most people need a secret or two. Most of the time.... the shit people hide from each other is more likely to be hidden because it's something stupid and embarassing rather than that it's something that actually matters.
@WordsandThoughts@xanga - Agreed 1000%. People in relationships are entitled to privacy. If an SO gets paranoid everytime I call or text someone that isnt him, it so will not work out.
@astudyinemerald@xanga - I agree.
@simply_surveys321@xanga - Good question, and I totally trust him. I don't go through his phone psychotically or like search for things. But if his phone is near me and he gets a text, I read it if I feel like it. He does the same for my phone. We don't see what the big deal is in it I guess.
I think the line is drawn here with the difference between dating and married. If we're dating, no, it's not your business. But if we're married, then it is. Marriage unites two people into a sort of whole, it's like you become one. That's not the case when you're dating.
@raspbxrrryjam@xanga - I agree. I feel if I asked, I should be able too and there should be nothing to hide. But I feel absolutely no need or desire to go through his phone. Not because I'm afraid too, but I trust him enough and have enough faith in our relationship to not feel the need.
And hes the same way with me. Its just mutual respect of each other privacy and trust of each other. If he asked, no doubt I'd let him see cause I have nothing to hide. Same with him. But also the same if someone is calling and hes not in the room, I dont mind looking and bringing it to him and saying "oh it's so and so".The issue here is rights and privliges. Just because you're in a long term serious relationship does not give you the right to act that way and expect the same in return. Only if it's accepted and acknowledged as okay. Only as long as the privlage is there. And to what extent? That also must be communicated.
I don't make my SO tell me all the names of every one of his friends, I don't make him show me his phone, I don't think that all of his business is my business. Even if it was a mutual friend texting, I would say "Oh it's so and so texting you" and then if he said to open it and read it to him, I would. If he didn't, I'd leave it alone, and continue what I was doing.
The fact of the matter is people text all the time, and sometimes they text very personal information about their life, or what is happening. If I was to open a text from a mutual friend that was ONLY FOR MY SO'S eyes, I don't think it's very respectful to our friend... and it's NONE of my business until that friend decides to tell me.
He would never off limits his phone to me, but I only use it while we're out for internet access when I'm bored, or need to check my email. I'm not going to be all over his shit, because I feel entitled. People like their privacy, they like to know that they have something that is theirs still even though they are with someone. It would drive me absolutely insane, and I would probably get rid of my phone if I was with someone who was constantly going through my phone.
I COMPLETELY AGREE. YOU GO GIRL!
You know, though I very much so appreciate your point, and totally encourage an open book lifestyle, I kindof feel like your point of view is a bit off the deep end. In a good steady relationship, trust totally should be at full reign, there should be no secrets whatsoever... however, the problem I have with your thought process here, is that -- your boyfriends business is his business and his alone. You, as the girlfriend, have every right to ask him any question about whats going on, you have every right to be fully informed, but its kindof stepping over the line to go through one's mail or online account, or phone or whatever, without them knowing or giving permission before hand. Yes, nothing should be shared, but that is a complete invasion of privacy. Your life is completely separate from his, just as his is from you. The problem comes in, in the fact that being invasive like this it leaves little room for trust and faith in your partner. You have no reason to trust him because you have all of his information at his fingertips. And i dont know about you, but faith and trust are aspects of a relationship that I wouldn't want to diminish. And besides, if nothing else, sometimes his business really just isn't any of your business. No matter how much you might think it is, it simply is not. There are some things that you should not know. Case in point -- what happens if a friend or relative or someone he trusts confides something very serious in him, and expect him to keep that information quiet. Should you come across that at some point, you have not only invaded your boyfriends privacy, but you have also invaded the privacy of the person who deeply confided in him.
And to be honest, I would be very hard to believe that your boyfriend is totally cool with you being so invasively knowledgeable about his life.
Once again, "hey, sweetheart, what did that text say?" or "Who just called? What did they want?" is a lot different than helping yourself to his personal life. Be careful! This kindof thing is a brooding ground for resentment and anger.
as long as he is okay with it, and he can do the same, i don't see why there would be a problem.
My boyfriend and I share your beliefs. I might get embarrassed when my boyfriend reads some of my texts (because they're mostly about him and how awesome he is). But, we don't hide anything from each other at all. We're pretty much best friends in boyfriend/girlfriend form.
There's a huge difference between answering a text you just so happened to get while playing with his phone & looking through his phone & emails, trying to find evidence of infidelity. I see nothing wrong with what you did.
I think it's fine as long as it's agreed upon. But...I would only do it if you said "hey, you just got a text from so-and-so" and he was like "what does it say". Otherwise I wouldn't even have the desire to read it anyway.
Wow, insecure much?
Have you ever thought that maybe he has friends who don't want you to know all the personal things about their lives they've ever talked to him about?
You complement him. Don't try to be him.
@WordsandThoughts@xanga - Agreed unless you ask him..then it wouldn't be. If you're not sure if it could be an invasion of privacy ask..