Sunday, 15 August 2010

  • The Thing About Rape



    The other day, I was watching some movie on the Indie channel.  I cannot remember for the life of me what it was called, but it was about a girl band that wanted to make it to the big time, found a manager and began to do it.  It was pretty old, I'm guessing, because not only was Julia Roberts looking younger than her "Pretty Woman" self, but she was a sideline role.

    Anyway, the movie sucked, but one scene caught my attention and has continued to recapture it on and off for the past couple of weeks at the most random times.    It featured young Julia - she was at a party, and this guy focused all of his attention on her throughout the entire event.  They were talking, laughing, and seemingly hitting it off when he decided it was time to take things inside. 

    Julia was naive, and didn't know what this implied.  She obligingly went with him, and was shocked when he closed the door to the room that they entered, and suddenly started to make out with her.  She went with this somewhat hesitantly, but when he pressed himself against her and started to put his hands up her dress she started to bat him away. 

    This went on for a while, and eventually she started yelling.  She said "What are you doing?!" to which he responded with the same question, and she yelled again - "I thought you LIKED me!".  "I do!" he said, "Which is why I want to make love to you!" (something along those lines) to which she said something like "Well I don't want you to, so stop! It's almost like you'd prefer I stopped moving so that you could just pound my body in peace!" 

    And every girl reading this knows how he replied already, but I'll put it in writing nonetheless: "I would." 

    Guess what she did?  She took a vase and cracked it over his head.

    Now, gentlemen viewers, be not afraid:  What is coming is far from being a rant about the male sex against the inherent vulnerability of their female counterparts.  I must preface Part II with the sheer fact that I am WELL aware that not all men are like the one described above, by any means whatsoever.  I recognize that most men reading this are probably thinking about what a dick guys like the described really are.  Please - read on.

    The reason that this scene has stuck so absurdly vividly in my mind - details as arbitrary as the furniture in the room they're in, the dress she's wearing, and especially the tones of both of their voices - is because of the intense repulsion that I felt upon acknowledging my own initial reaction to the scene.  It's even reflected in my above description.  It was not to the man's behavior in the slightest - he's a GUY, I thought to myself.  Of COURSE that's what he's after if he's taking you inside, you dumbass, why the HELL did you go with him?

    And my little internal rant didn't stop there.  It went on: Was a VASE cracked over his HEAD really necessary?  I mean, it seems a little extreme.

    This is when repulsion set in, because I remembered "the thing about rape."  I learned it in the one "Women, Gender and Sexuality Studies" course I ever took, and it is as follows: Rape is implanted into the heads of women as a controlling device from the time they are born.  It is a constant reminder of their lower position, of their vulnerability, and of their weakness.  That we as women are open holes to be guarded or invaded by men, and we are dependent upon the protection of the majority so that invasion by the bad minority can be prevented.

    And this was supported by various case studies and statistical facts, and these studies and facts led to a very important realization for me and most of the rest of my class - that generally, when a woman fights her rapist, she escapes.  That when she actively tries to get away, she usually does.

    But this escape is rare, because all of this psychodrama about "fight or flight" is a load of bullshit when it comes to something as socially internalized as rape.  There is a fear so deeply ingrained that there is usually no amount of adrenaline sufficient enough to supply a woman with a method to fight or fly. The fear simply paralyzes, and like our mentors Snow White and Sleeping Beauty, we lie there helplessly and wait for Prince Charming to rescue us. 

    Unfortunately, the only person who ever seems to have a "happy ending" is the rapist.

    I strongly believe this whole "thing."  I consider myself a strong woman.  I stick up for myself, and for what I believe in.  I defend the people that I love.  I have a clear idea of what I want, what's right, and what's wrong - and how these three "whats" tie together in any given situation.

    Nonetheless, I (with horror and an excruciatingly painful sense of regret) have come to accept the fact that I am no exception to the general rule.  That I, like most women, give in and give up rather than fighting or flying to my way to freedom when faced with the overwhelming power of a man with unrelenting sexual desires.

    Furthermore, that I expect everyone to do the same.  That I follow a social code that encourages women to oblige requests, to "lighten up and loosen up" or else stop dressing so goddamned provocatively.  To stop "asking for it" if they don't want it.  To stop "putting themselves in the wrong situations," or getting so absurdly drunk. 

    To make out with someone only with the reasonable expectation that more will be sought after, and that it is you who are to blame for being so uptight, selfish, or naive that you fail to live up to them by hitting someone over the head with a vase.

    I am a perpetuator of "the thing."  "The thing" that we know lurks in the woods on the way to Grandmother's house when we are young girls, and that we know lurks in the street corners on the way home from work.  I support and promote it.  I could not be more ashamed.

    I'd love to wrap this up with some kind of uplifting suggestion or solution, but the ability to do so would imply a smaller problem than there is.  We all perpetuate this problem, and we are all - men and women alike - so awfully affected by it.  To fix it would require not only a change in all of our various effective actions and behaviors (my apologies to those few true exceptions), but also a change in all of our patterns of regular thought. 

    This solutional task seems quite impossible to me, and mimics the problem itself by demanding nothing more than complete and utter defeat in response to what it poses.  With this sense of defeat looming over me, I can only think it appropriate to follow regular suit by ending with a request for help:

    How do we solve this problem?  How do we even start?

Comments (86)

  • anonymous

    I don't know who your health teacher was but I guess you can blame them for your ignorance.


    Most rape victims when trying to escape don't get away, most cannot over power their rapist THAT IS A FACT. Desperate. Just desperate.

  • prosperitastenuisdecorus@xanga

    what you said is extremely true. i just think women need to be educated and it needs to be ingrained in their heads that they have a right to their own bodies. a woman should be able to dress however she wants without worrying that she's "asking for it." women need more self-respect. they need to learn to be fighters. they need to embrace their agressive nature.

  • prosperitastenuisdecorus@xanga

    @come on now - i disagree. yes, sometimes they can be overpowered, what when the men have knives and such but the psychological aspect she discusses is absolutely a factor and absolutely true.

  • anonymous

    And further more don't end this like you are trying to prevent or educate people on rape. This obviously written by a guy and if it isn't it is written by a very unintelligent misygonist women who lacks education. Respond with oh well I got my ph.d at harvard whatever you are just another ignorant person online you want to educate women on rape? You want to help defeat it? Here are some facts:


    MOST PEOPLE ARE RAPED BY PEOPLE THEY KNOW, NOT STRANGERS OR PEOPLE THEY JUST MET. MOST RAPIST ESTABLISH A RELATIONSHIP WITH THEIR VICTIM IN ORDER TO GAIN TRUST. BUT ACQUAINTANCE RAPE, RELATIVE RAPE, ETC. IS THE MOST POPULAR RAPE MOST RAPE VICTIMS HAVE NO NEED TO FEAR THE RAPIST UNTIL THEY ARE BEING RAPED THAT IS A FACT. THE SCENERIO YOU GAVE IS A MOVIE SCENERIO NOT A REAL LIFE ONE. FURTHER MORE IF YOU ARE ABOUT TO BE RAPED NOTHING IS TO EXTREME NOT A VASE, NOT NOTHING IN PROTECTING YOURSELF. WHAT WOULD YOU SAY IF IT HAPPENED TO YOU?


    ANOTHER WAY YOU CAN HELP STOP GIVING OUT FALSE INFORMATION IN PETTY VINDACTION BECAUSE YOU MAY THINK YOU ARE ACCOMPLISHING SOMETHING BUT YOU AREN'T. EVEN YOU'RE PATHETIC GOAL TO GET UNDER SOMEONE'S SKIN ISN'T WORKING.


    GROW UP ALREADY


    I AM SORRY YOU HATE YOURSELF AND DO THINGS LIKE THIS TO MAKE YOURSELF FEEL BETTER BUT THE TRUTH IS IF I CARRIED ON LIKE YOU I WOULDN'T LIKE MYSELF EITHER. TRY HELPING INSTEAD OF HURTING THEN MAYBE YOU WOULDN'T FEEL THEY NEED  TO DO THIS


    ONLY THE UNINTELLIGENT AND IMMATURE BULLY

  • roxics@xanga

    We start by me kicking the rapists ass. A woman should never be put in that situation. Women are to be respected. That's how you get the pussy. 

  • ImGoingGhost@xanga

    @come on now - Either you've been abused, or know someone who has. I've been abused. Burned beaten tortured and violated. I don't scream at other people and get upset. I focus on getting stronger. 

  • AmeliaHart@xanga

    Huh???? You think that if a woman "fights back" then her rapist will stop???? PLENTY OF WOMEN have physically fought back... That doesn't stop rape. 

    I think you're confused....

  • unabridgedtales@xanga

    I honestly think you're giving "gender roles" too much credit in this post. Yes, some rapes stop if people fight back, and yes, many freeze instead of fight... but do remember that generally guys have more upper body strength than girls and tend to be bigger, so even if a girl fights, she's probably not going to be able to stop it unless she grabs some kind of weapon or gets lucky. I don't think there's as much of a "lay down and take it" mentality as you've suggested.

    @come on now - I think it's interesting that you're calling this poster - someone who regularly submits here - "an unintelligent and immature bully" after three paragraphs in caps and anonymously.

    I don't think you're stupid by any means, especially because I know much of what you said is true (yes, those who are raped usually know the rapist, but there ARE scenarios like the movie; also, I don't think the movie was showing rape as much as a guy trying to convince a girl, so maybe the vase wasn't in order, but I didn't see it so I don't know)...

    It doesn't look good if you say things like "This obviously written by a guy and if it isn't it is written by a very unintelligent misygonist women who lacks education. Respond with oh well I got my ph.d at harvard whatever you are just another ignorant person online," and call the person immature. Just sayin'.

    I respect that you have issues with this post, as I do too, but you're coming off as childish. :|

  • Art_Is_War423@xanga

    Wow.

    Ok- bottom line; no matter how you dress, how drunk you are, how long you kiss, etc, no means NO. There is no excuse for continuing on after hearing those words. If you have to bash a guy over the head with a vase to get it through to him, so be it.

    We are not simply holes for males to stick it in at will. We are not here simply for their pleasure.

  • Art_Is_War423@xanga

    @roxics@xanga - =] you're totally awesome.

    @AmeliaHart@xanga - i know, right? Especially since rape is an act of dominance & rapists usually like it when the women fight back.

  • anonymous

    @ImGoingGhost@xanga - Ooooo somone get this man his ph d!!!! He is psychic or a genius! Yes I have been raped. It's the one thing in the world I feel we don't get angry about enough. Infact initially after I was raped, I blamed myself, what I wore, what I did, victimized my rapist and as a result went nuts. It took my therapist, my psychiatrist and other educated people to tell me TO GET ANGRY. I am a happy peaceful person but when it comes to violence to rape, I scream if I feel I need to be loud. Getting attention on rape education is important. You, this blog, the blog author are ignorant. It's time to shut and listen and if you won't hear it will scream so you do. Funny it should come out like that. I asked me rapist to stop...his defense? He couldn't hear me...lol


    But considering you have a cartoon character as your avatar eludes to your intelligence as well as your maturity level so how made can I get a guy who has Johnny Phantom as a symbol of who he is...

  • unabridgedtales@xanga

    @come on now - I'm sorry for what you've been through, and I hope you have a wonderful future.

  • ImGoingGhost@xanga

    @come on now - I don't see the future, and I don't believe in psychology. I feel sad for you, because this is your way to vent. You are hurt, afraid, and angry at the world. Deep down, you want someone to acknowledge your pain.  I am an empath. It means I feel what you feel. Which is why I just stood up for you, to someone else, and asked them to leave you be. It's on their page, in their comment section. 

  • o0_Innocent_0o@xanga

    @come on now - Its funny how you call the poster of this post an "unintelligent and immature bully", when you've literally lashed out in three paragraphs, telling her to "grow up already" (sorry, the one who needs to grow up isn't the one screaming their head off), as well as describing the poster as a "very unintelligent misygonist WOMAN (woman is singular, m'dear) who lacks education. Rather childish, don't you know.


    However, I do agree that most people are raped by people they know. But I think that the scenerio she gave was simply an example. Movies aren't always real (: If it is, I'd love to be in Inception with Joseph Gordon-Levitt... ANYWAYS, although you do have a point, please respond in a manner where you don't contradict yourself... and perhaps find a dictionary.

  • anonymous

    @unabridgedtales@xanga - I don't care how I am coming off. Obviously writting it anonymously I don't care. What I care about is my message, not my delivery. You even said everything I said was true so what do I care about online ettiquette? I am not hear to sound eloquent or grammatically correct I am hear to educate people and call them out on their ignorance. I don't care about my image or style or what people think I care about what people KNOW and they need to KNOW the truth. If it came across as angry GOOD. It is angry. I am a rape victim, sister of a rape victim, child of a rape victim, friend of many rape victims and this blame the victim crap most STOP. Who cares about online etiquette or coming off as childish or not. Red this freaking post nothing I say unless its googoogaga is going to sound my childish then this adolence misogynist excuse for rape which is the real issue. I don't feel anything I said in their is childish, smart ass, and maybe a little unnecessary yes but the truth is? SO THIS POST. Desperate desperate desperate.


    I DON'T CARE HOW I COME OFF JUST WHAT THE OVER ALL MESSAGE IS. And if my online etiquette distracts people from the truth that is their superficialness conquiring them from obtaining knowledge on an issue.

  • anonymous

    @ImGoingGhost@xanga - Obviously you don't know me at all child lol I am not hurt nor sad or even angry but rape and justification of rape MAKES ME ANGRY.


    As for defending me online DON'T especially if you are going to matyr yourself for it.


    I stood up to my rapist, all by myself got him thrown in jail but attacking me or even drawing the attention to me and not to what I said is wrong. Listen to what I am saying those are THE FACTS OF RAPE.


    I live a happy wonderful life and educate people day to day on rape. I have loving friends and family and I am proud to be a survivor.


    I pity you because you feel that you need to creep people out and be weird online to feel like you are important. You need lots of attention so you come here.


    This isn't how I vent THIS IS HOW I STAND UP FOR EVERY GIRL THAT HAS BEEN RAPED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • CrAdLe2daGrAve@xanga

    @roxics@xanga - i was with you up until the part you said "That's how you get the pussy." yeah you ain't gettin' none anytime soon...

  • CrAdLe2daGrAve@xanga

    can we just end it by saying rape is something serious and it's a horrible thing to inflict on another human being?

  • roxics@xanga

    @CrAdLe2daGrAve@xanga - I have a GF so yeah I kinda am. Anyway. What's wrong with what I said? Being a good guy is the right way to get laid over being a rapist. 

  • anonymous

    @o0_Innocent_0o@xanga - LOL women and woman is a mistake I make often as a typo but I know the difference. Thanks. But aren't you the smart one? But here is one genius: How can I scream online? Putting it in caps isn't screaming hon, you can only do that out loud, do you understand or should I grab you the dictionary so you can look up and find out what screaming is? So maybe you shouldn't contradict yourself my dear. I know you come here to feel smart, talking to someone you don't know based on one comment they make and I am not here to announce my intelligence nor do I need to PUT DOWN SOMEONE DEFENDING RAPE VICTIMS TO MAKE MYSELF FEEL SMART. :D


    I think yelling at a bully isn't contradicting, it's meeting fire with fire and it's the only thing that bullies respond to.


    I wrote in anger so there are mistakes. But like I said, I don't care how it comes off I just care about the facts that I wish everyone would focus on instead of being so petty and as a self proclaimed smart person honey, I would of figured you would of done that.


     

  • o0_Innocent_0o@xanga

    @come on now - LOL its okay, I make stranger typos.. Okay okay. We're both contradicting ourselves, how bout that? I dont come here to feel smart. I know I responded to your comment even though I don't know you personally, but really, aren't most of us here doing that anyways? You don't know the poster either. I dont think o-o Also, I really doubt the poster was being a bully. But I'm not the poster, so I wouldn't know. It's a mere assumption. Although you're trying to make a point, and give out some facts, the caps WERE rather distracting. Just to me, not sure about anyone else, but they were to me.


    BUT! Props to you, because even though you went through all that, you're still here today with a wonderful life like you said you have. I'm not sure I'd be able to do that.

  • CrAdLe2daGrAve@xanga

    @roxics@xanga - nothing i didn't say you were a bad guy or nothing... but since you have a GF... it's a diff story but if you didn't... you wouldn't get none if you had that last part... 

  • Hinase@xanga

    @Art_Is_War423@xanga - I agree with that.


    We women, should be respect period. It may not always happen but we need to be. And no, means no regardless.
    Again I discredit this post. Apparently people are offended by this post..I don't feel like reading the entire thing..>.> too much really.
  • Erika_Steele@xanga

    I hope you can continue to make naive statements about rape based on what you learned from movies.

  • starving__art1st@xanga

    @CrAdLe2daGrAve@xanga - i don't really understand the issue here.. you say he's not going to get pussy because he said respect will earn him pussy? Well, it's true. If someone treats me with respect they're more likely to get the goods than if they treated me like crap. Does it offend you that he said "get some pussy"? i hear chicks say "get some dick" all the time.

    Chill. They're just words. You don't have to go all women's rights on someone just because they like sex. As long as they're going about it the right way, really, what's the problem?

  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

  • FionaMay
    • From: FionaMay
    • Name: FionaMay
    • About Me: I wish we could all stay in the "dating" part of relationships forever. It's the most anxiety-ridden part of anything serious, that's for sure, but it's also the most fun! I hope I can find someone who will date me forever...hey, he'd save money on a ring!
    Stats: This Week All Time
    Posts: 0 53
    Views: 0 109208
    Comments: 0 1644
    View all posts by FionaMay