Saturday, 22 May 2010
-
Why People ACTUALLY Stay in Abusive Relationships

A couple days ago, someone wrote a post that was featured on datingish about abusive relationships. It was titled, "There's Another Reason Why People Stay In Abusive Relationships", perhaps you saw it? I was appalled; why was this guy writing about something he clearly has no idea about. He basically stated the reason people stay in their abusive relationships is because they have a desire to beat the person at their own game, covertly. Really? I wonder if he was he just trying to start a debate, or if he truly believes that.I completely disagree with him. But instead of just saying his point of view is totally off, I thought I'd give more accurate reasons.
Lots of people recognize that they are being mistreated or even abused, but they choose to stay in the relationship for a number of reasons. It's never easy to end a relationship, even a hurtful one. When friends or family ask, "Why don't you just leave?" it may be hard to explain it. But there are reasons why you stay.
- Love. You love your partner, and there are still times when your partner is very loving.
- Hope. You may have many memories of happy times, and hope those times will return. Your partner may promise to change, or you may think if you do things differently, the abuse will stop.
- Making light of the abuse. Your partner may deny that his or her behavior is abusive, or act as if it's not such a big deal, and you want to believe this. It's very painful to admit that someone you love would hurt you, so you might try to convince yourself it's not really that bad.
- Blaming yourself. Your partner might blame you for his or her abusive behavior- saying you made them angry, or that you did something to deserve it. A part of you may believe this.
- Link between love and violence. If you grew up in a home where there was violence, or if you were ever hit by a parent, and told they were doing it because they loved you, you might have learned to think that love and violence go together.
- Hopelessness. You may feel like you'll never be able to be happy, you'll never find a new partner who treats you any better, or that all relationships include abuse.
- Gender roles. If you are a women in a relationship with a man, you may have learned from family, religion, or culture that men are supposed to be in charge, can't help being violent, or have the right to discipline their women. You may believe that women have to put up with this behavior and try to keep their men happy.
- Embarrassment and shame. You may not want to admit what's going on to other because you're afraid of what they will think about you.
- Financial dependence. You may depend in your partner for financial support.
- Lack of supportive relationship. You may have become isolated from your friends and family. Or, family and friends may pressure you to stay with you partner.
- Fear. Your partner may have threatened to hurt or kill you or someone you care about, if you leave.
- Not wanting to be alone. You may panic at the thought of being without your partner.
- Loyalty. You may feel the right thing to do is stick with your partner no matter what.
- Rescue complex. You think you can change, fix, or heal your partner if you stay.
- Guilt. Your partner may make you feel guilty about how much it would hurt them if you left. They threaten to commit suicide.
- Children. If you have children with your partner, you may believe it is best for the child to have two parents who are together.
- Dependency on drugs or alcohol. Many people use drugs or alcohol as a way of coping with abuse, which then makes them less clear and strong and makes it more difficult to leave.
I was in an sexually abusive relationship, as many of you may know, and not once did I think, "Heck, if I stay with Richard maybe I can get back at him. Perhaps I can find his weakness, and become the one in-control." Hell no!
Out of the seventeen reasons listed above, I can identify with Love, Hope, Making light of the abuse, Blaming myself, Hopelessness, Gender role, Embarrassment and shame, Lack of supportive relationships, Fear, Loyalty, Rescue complex, and Guilt; but definitely not revenge.
1. I thought, he loves me, he doesn't mean to hurt me. 2. Maybe this time will be the last time, maybe it won't happen again like he promises. 3. It isn't that big of a deal, it'll happen when we're married, right? 4. Maybe I brought this one somehow, I did something to make him horny.. 6. He's my first boyfriend, maybe he's the only one that I will love ever. 7. He can't help it, he's a guy. 8. They'll think I'm a whore! I don't want to know I'm not innocent anymore. 10. They'll all say I told you so. They warned me about his age. 11. What will he do if I try to leave? 13. I have a strong sense of loyalty, I don't want to turn my back on anything. 14. He'll change. He's lost so much, I can't leave him also. 15. I can be easily guilted and he knew that and used it to his advantage.
Whatever reason you have for staying in an abusive relationship I doubt you're doing it for revenge. I don't think anyone who knew what they were talking about would say that.
Can you identify with any of these reasons? Do you agree?
Post a Comment
- Back to datingish's Datingish Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in datingish's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)


Recommend


Comments (74)
I agree with you 100%. I've been through an abusive relationship myself..physically, verbally, sexually, you name it, it happened. I stayed with him for a majority of those reasons on your list. I figured it wasn't anything to make a big deal over, I was scared to leave him, I didn't want him hurting me/my family...it was just a terrible situation. I couldn't imagine staying with him because I wanted to 'get back at him' though..Some people might, I guess?
More accurate reasons, in your own opinion. People have many reasons. Also, you might want to try avoiding Ad Hominem; it weakens your argument and makes you seem childish.
thankfully i am not in a abusive relationship like that.. its only verbal abuse sometimes.. but we both are a part of that and in the end we tell eachother sorry..and try to better ourselves.. but i like the list and i agree how a person can stay due to any number of those reasons. i can identify however with love, hope, definitely blaming myself, loyalty and making light of abuse.
good post!
Really? I thought it was because of sex, low self esteem, and a fix complex.(maybe she/he will be better if I can change them).
All of the above except for the drug and alcohol component mentioned, were reasons for keeping me stuck in the relationship, as well as a religious component where I'd been brainwashed into thinking that it was my religious duty to stay despite the abuse and that I'd be leaving the religion and encurring the wrath of God if I were to leave.
It is very hard to leave an abusive relationship and normally takes many attempts for women to do so. For me it took a total of three times (of actually leaving) before I was able to break away fully (and many attempts at leaving that were stopped by him). My relationship was abusive physically, emotionally, sexually, verbally, financial, religious etc... I blamed myself for everything and what made it worse was him blaming me and telling me that I was making a "big deal out of nothing" when I did have the courage to try to stand up against him.
@SlackerSociety@xanga - many more reasons than that.
it's surprising how many of us have been or are in an abusive relationship. everyones relationship is different but your reasons hit pretty close to home.
i stayed because i was young and naive, and scared. i agree with a lot of these
@SlackerSociety@xanga - Haha!
And I wasn't appalled. what I saw he did was that he saw much more dimensions to abusive relationship. for some, there is a question of exactly why he is doing that, and how much can that person take, before they can make him behave, even if that means mind games. I thought his explanation of there being also a deeper situation to staying in was something of interest, because it made me wonder if anyone who did do that had any plans of pulling it off. Eitehr way, to me, abusive relationships are a matter of control or something deeper. Whatever you do, its about power and trying to control the other person. So, the idea of someone trying to gain back control with the same bit of revenge is another kinda-complex situation entirely, and is only farfetched, because the idea isn't so common or some people aren't always that mental when it comes to matters of love and lackthereof.
Fantastic post! I have a hard time explaining it to people why I stayed in one... maybe I wll just show them this!
hope was the number reason. it gave me a reason to stay and it was my pride that gave me a reason to leave.
hey, some of us liked being slapped and pinned down.
My reasons from that list are: love, hope, hopelessness, making light of the abuse (to some extent on my part because of my forgiving nature), financial dependence, lack of supportive relationship (sort of), not wanting to be alone, loyalty, and rescue complex.
in 1997 [i was 13] my mother was Murdered by her husband. it was not the first time he hit her, more like the 1,000th. drugs, alcohol and rage were a key component to his abuse... and fear was the reason my mom stayed. if you hear " if you try to leave i will kill you" enough times, you believe it. and in her case it was true. i remember many times her being beaten severally, broken bones and black eyes were a common thing in my house. somehow at 13 years old i managed to make the decision to move in with my real father, and leave my mother and 3 year old sister in hell. 2 days after Christmas my dad told me that my mom had been killed. she had been found with the back of her head caved in, from it being pounded into the floor, her breasts were crushed because he had been sitting on her.. and the fetus she was carrying that would have been my baby brother was dead as well. he got 5 to 15 years in jail. He is out now. the justice system is fucked. [thats not really the point.]
the point i am trying to get to, i guess is just... dont stay. there is no reason to stay and die. if you are in an abusive situation.. even if they are telling you they will kill you if you leave.... get out as fast as you can. dont take your stuff, dont say good bye. get up in the night, get your kids and leave. figure out the rest later. because i am telling you if you stay you WILL die. if not by his hands then by your own. my mom tried to kill herself 3 times that i know of... because i think on some level she knew that death was going to be her only way out.
I think the guy's post was suggesting that maybe the woman will become psycho like the abuser and do something extremely crazy like in movies where they gradually lace the spouse's food with poison so they'll slowly suffer and die, but if both are psycho then it'll just be constant heated arguements where it is an actual debate than one sided abuse, which probably most abusive relationships are. I think abusers continue to do it because they know that the woman fears him and most likely won't rebel because they aren't evil like the abuser. I think abusers might have a warped sense of what being a man is because they might've been brainwashed by their own macho father to believe that keeping your woman in check by verbal/physical/sexual dominance and controlling her to obey is manly when it is rather cowardly that he abuses someone that loves and trusts him so she is easier to manipulate.
I've seen a topic on the steve wilkos show about abusive relationships where the abuser was only a bully to his girlfriend but he was scared of his mother, who seemed to verbally abuse him and he looked afraid of her as she yelled at him, so it was like he was also taking out his emotional repression on his gf, which made him feel like a man again because his mother made him feel so small and he was in prison so he had to act like a tough guy in order to not get bullied or he got bullied and felt vulnerable and needed to regain his sense of control, which doesn't excuse his behavior but it was interesting to find out the psychological reasonings behind the abuser as well as the one being abused. he admitted that he was scared and insecure that she would leave him because she did try to leave many times but was afraid because he threatened her safety by continuing to verbally & physically abuse her. he locked her in the house to keep her from leaving him, so it was like being in prison, which I think he lost his freedom when he was in prison, so it seems like a twisted way to get back his control by taking the freedom and power away from his girlfriend. it doesn't justify their cruel behavior but abusers have serious insecurity issues themselves by using psychological transference. anyway she loved him and wanted him to change, so steve wilkos acted like those bootcamp sergeants and set him straight and he was actually very intimidated and scared of steve when he yelled at him for not being a real man while staring him directly in the eyes
later the couple update was that she was pregnant and he was finally a changed man, who now treats her with love and respect. so in this case, she sought help and stayed in hopes that he'll change, which he did. although that doesn't always happen due to difference situations.
You got it.
Excellent post.
Great post. Everything you said is dead on.
i agree with you. i can relate to some of those reasons when i was in an abusive relationship. i was able to get out once my sister told me that i was right.
P90X Extreme Fitness System ONLY ONLY 42$$$$$$$
sorry to disturb u. just take u a little time.
If you are in need,
welcome to : http://www.clotheshops.us
50%off ca,ed hardy t-shirt$15 jeans,coach handbag$33,air max90,dunk,polo t-shirt$13,,lacoste t-shirt $13 air jordan for sale,l nba jersy for sale sale,$35,nfl nba jersy for sale
free shipping
accept paypal credit card
lower price fast shippment with higher quality
BEST QUALITY GUARANTEE!!
SAFTY & HONESTY GUARANTEE!!
FAST & PROMPT DELIVERY GUARANTEE!!
Packing: All the products are packed with original boxes and tags also retro cards/ code
numder
Features: AAA QUALITY, COMPETITIVE PRICE AND SERVICE
1) The goods are shipping by air express, such as EMS,the shipping time is in 5-7 business days
2) They are in stock now;
3) Various styles and color for clients’ choice
4) The Products are fit for most people, because of our wholesale price
puma gucci$35,nike jordans six ring,yeezy$%5!!
new era caps$13 gucci handbags jeans,t-shirts sunglass,caps
true religion jeans$35,ca,ed hardy jeans$35
LV,CHANAL,HANDBAGS$35
NIKE SHOX+AIR MAX+TL3+OZ+NZ ONLY $35
UGG TIMBLAND+LACOSTE SHOES+ED HARDY SHOES$35
DIESEL T-SHIRT,GSTAR T-SHIRT,CA T-SHIRT,50% OFF FOR SALE $15
DIOR SUNGLASS,DG SUNGLASS$15
our website: http://www.clotheshops.us
The only reason people stay in abusive relationships is because they're stupid.
That's more or less the only reason.
This is much more accurate.
I tried to just not read that post. I saw the bolded parts, said whatever, and moved on.
Being in a relationship like that myself, I agree with your reasons entirely.
I completely agree with you, although maybe that guy's reason applies to someone he knows. :P
Great post. Although I was never in an abusive relationship, I've tried to explain to people while women might stay. Unfortunately, a lot of men have told me that these women and stupid and selfish for doing so. It breaks my heart when a man feels this way, hopefully this will enlighten some.