Monday, 09 November 2009
-
Feminism: Guys Getting Whipped
The discussion topic was focused on how brainless Disney characters girls were. It was all about finding the prince and nothing else seemed to remotely matter. Well before we start on any further discussion, I just like to say, lighten up!Yes, I agree girls should have a mind of their own. They should pursue other things in life other than "Mr Right." But sometimes I think society (present generation, and since feminism started) tries too hard (note: I say sometimes, so don't come bashing me down already) to almost alienate their roles as a girl, as a female.
If you were to ask me my honest opinion, my answer would be: no, I do not think women can be stronger than men. (shocking!) Well, obviously it is not impossible (because very often we do, wink) for girls to over exceed men in whatever they might be on taking (whether it is a career, leadership or knowledge etc) but I think sometimes we should make a conscious effort not to, especially if we are in a relationship with one. Yes it is simply that; testerone and egos. It might not necessarily be the most valid reasons to justify being weaker, but somehow this is how the different genders have been wired, and if you really look at it..beautiful in it's own respective ways.
I am just brought up on the concrete knowledge that women are equal or below men. Not in disrespectful way, or an inferior way, but in a beautiful, weaker sense. That women are there to be taken care of. By the men: the stronger gender. If you were to take it straight from the oldest book of all time, the Bible..there's a saying that goes: From Adam's ribs, Eve was created:
Woman was created from the rib of man.
She was not made from his head to be above him,
nor was she made from his feet to be trampled on.
She was created out of his side to equal him,
under his arm to be protected by him
and near his heart to be loved.That said, I know there's always another side to a coin. One thing I will not take lying down no matter what though; is being disrespected or mistreated in a relationship. I have and always been the kind of girl with the stern mindset of respecting oneself and if you actually somehow stupidly allow yourself to be disrespected and mistreated and not attempt to get out of it, then obviously you don't love or respect yourself enough. And I reckon if you don't love yourself or pride yourself highly enough to respect yourself, then really don't expect people to respect or love you. As cliche as it sounds, you must first, love yourself. I will not hesitate to bring any guy down if they do not show why they are worth our respect. Many things in life must be earned. (because baby, we all know things do not come that easily)
But overall, if the guy/s deserves it, we should then definitely make the effort to respect him no matter what; whether it is in front of his peers or alone. Acknowledging his role as a male and aiming to be his partner working alongside him. Aiding him to be the best person he can be and not climbing above his head or putting him down just because we feel like it. Or maybe just for the sake of feminism (because oh you know girls are SO strong nowadays and we must have a say in everything). I reckon, we should just simply allow males to be males and females to be...females. Beautiful, simple, innocent in their own special way. On an emotional side note: question shout out to all the girls..isn't it just plain normal to want to be 'weaker' to the guy anyway? Don't you feel sweeter? More protected that way? Sounds and looks a bit crude seeing a guy getting whipped by a girl..hrms.
So, what do you think? Agree or disagree?
Post a Comment
- Back to datingish's Datingish Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in datingish's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)













Comments (93)
i hate it when feminists say women aren't dependent on men or don't need men. yes, we are, and yes, we do. the relationship between women and men is a codependent one. if women didn't need men and vice versa, there wouldn't be two of us.
and women are not as physically strong as men. i absolutely hate it when women call that a stereotype. no, it's not a stereotype, it's a fact. take a man and a woman, give them the same weightlifting routine with the same weighted equipment, i guarantee you the man will be stronger. men have more testosterone, they are going to be stronger.
as far as emotionally stronger? well, i think that varies from person to person. women in general though are the weaker sex. do i think being weaker means that we're inferior? no, it just means that we're different. and we're supposed to be; we have different roles.
i have to be honest, i kind of just skipped around in this post and only got the majority, but i agree.
OK, I do agree that biologically there are some differences between men and women, but this line:
Not in disrespectful way, or an inferior way, but in a beautiful,
weaker sense. That women are there to be taken care of. By the men: the
stronger gender.
reeeeeally bothers me. I'm aromantic. I don't date anyone. I don't feel I need to be taken care of emotionally or otherwise by any man or woman. From this experience, I don't think men should be men and women should be women. What about men that want to be protected and women who want to protect? Really, that's up to them, who they want to be. Women and men should be who they want to be without having to feel they have to fulfill a role, especially in relationships. (Also, this view about women needing protection from men is extremely heteronormative as well, but I won't get into that.)
yeah i like girls kthnx. save yo preachin'.
@snapeful@xanga - LOL. See? Heteronormativity for the lose.
It's important to acknowledge that there are real differences between men and women, beyond the obvious. Muscle mass is one. Aggression is another; though both males and females express aggression, usually males use physical violence and females use deception and subtlety. (Men are to war as women are to espionage.)
Yet... I think that you have walked onto a slippery slope here. It's one thing to say that men are physically stronger and more likely to be physically aggressive... it's quite another to suggest that women should accept being inherently "weaker" and that feminism is fundamentally wrong.
Feminism has done wonderful things for our world: the mere fact that women can vote, own property, wear the clothes they want to wear---these are the achievements of feminism. Surely some feminists have gone too far (those who reject heterosexuality, for instance); perhaps the feminist movement in general has overstepped its bounds. But you cannot plausibly deny that feminism has done good things for the world.
Unfortunately, this will probably always be an issue in human society, because Homo sapiens is a just-barely dimorphic species. If we were radically dimorphic, like many insects, there would be no debate because males and females would be incorrigibly different. If instead we were virtually non-dimorphic, like hyenas, equality might well be obvious to anyone. But in our current state, there are real differences, yet they are mild and often overcome by individual variation; as such, feminism is at once necessary and problematic.
@salvatruca_stalking_havok13@xanga - Another point well taken.
I would like nothing more than to be given the opportunity to be the woman in a relationship and have him be the man...but I seem unable to find a man who wants to be a man such that you describe or who truly values a woman, such that you describe. It takes both to play their roles to fully allow the other to be all they can be.
Most attributes for both men and women have a wide distribution. Thus, while on the average, men may be physically stronger than women, there will be some women who are stronger than the average male and some men that are weaker than the average women. And so it goes with all other traits you may think differ between the sexes.
Therefore, we need to end gender discrimination and have equal opportunities for men and women based on the task requirements. Women and men and have a right to have equal access and equal wages for all jobs and careers for which they are capable.
And the role of 2 people in a relationship will depend on the needs and desires of those 2 people--it shouldn't be defined by society, the Bible, and certainly not by the government!
@salvatruca_stalking_havok13@xanga - I agree 100% with what you're saying. I think what she wrote belittles females, but in a sly, watered-down way. It's not okay to generalize females as weak damsels in distress. I'm fed up that people still think that way.
Complete equality is the only way to go.
@godofthelost@xanga - Exactly. I dont believe in "roles" for either side to be fair. Feminism got started because women wanted to be equal with men, not better. There's nothing wrong with that.
@salvatruca_stalking_havok13@xanga - ::HIGH FIVE::
*eyeroll*
Feminism does not mean "guys getting whipped" but good try. It means equality, choice, and personal responsibility. Saying, "women should ONLY behave like the inferior sex because in general, they are physically weaker," is the same as saying, "black people should ONLY live near the equator because they are biologically more suited for sunny climates."
Excellent post. I really don't have anything to add, but I felt the need to add props.
Feminism has done good things...but it's been growing incoherent and radical for quite awhile. I wish more people recognized this.
All I know is I love men, and I like being a girl. I know I won't be physically stronger than most guys. But that doesn't matter. I need guys around or I'll go crazy.
"...On an emotional side note: question shout out to all the girls..isn't
it just plain normal to want to be 'weaker' to the guy anyway? Don't
you feel sweeter? More protected that way?...."
No. Absolutely not. I feel belittled, like a kid. Also, I tend to choose men who are not much stronger than I am. It might be a subconscious defense mechanism; after all, a man who could "protect" me is the same man who could become angry while drunk and beat the crap out of me.
Also, anyone who says "women NEED men!" or "men also need women!" is underestimating the modern independent single person. It's nice to have a significant other, but by no means do I NEED mine.
There are a lot of guys that I am stronger than, can run faster than, and am more intelligent than. I don't make a point to do that, I just am. I like it, most of my friends are guys. I'm still feminine. I'm dating someone. I like skirts and shopping and high heels. I also like knowing that I can beat my friends in Halo. I don't need to be "weak" in order to feel protected by a man. That's just me.
Rubbish.
"Beautiful, simple, innocent in their own special way."
Your romanticization of femaleness makes me want to puke.
That said, feminism isn't about "guys getting whipped." It's about equality.
guys should never get whipped....it causes them to lose friends...and they become a social retard
I think it varies GREATLY from relationship to relationship, and down to person to person. If that's what you feel is right, I'm happy for you, and glad you have solid values... and to everyone who's denouncing her ideals in such a mean way, you have to remember that it's not up to her to tell you how to treat your SO or how you should demand to be treated. You also cannot tell her what to do. To each his own.
@IntrospectiveOctober@xanga - I wish there was a like button on xanga like on facebook :) ! Agreed... the biological deterministic fallacy at its worst
The devaluation of femininity while society simultaneously encourages women to fit into a clear feminine end of the dichotomy creates pressures on both directions that make you screwed no matter what as a woman. if you're feminine, you're too feminine for some feminists. if you're masculine in some ways, people start to criticize your for not being feminine enough.
That being said, the author's writing about what women should be like still makes me sort of ill. I'm not going to repress parts of myself for the sake of some man's ego you dumb twit.
If there's some percieved threat by men, then I'm not going to say "Oh poor little men might be trumped by a chick". I'm going to say, "May the best win"
@an_addictfor_dramatics@xanga - the author isn't doing much that harms others, and she could be doing a lot worse, but it is in fact perfectly okay to tell people when they're wrong. the alternative morally relativistic world is something i don't think you'd like very much either.
@msnatalie27@xanga - exactly! I suppose a lot of people don't actually know how much variation there is in biological expression or how much of a spectrum. I don't think people really know what it means for something to be biologically determined, or the fact that the environment and biology interact with each other.
Umm...NO that's not what feminism is about. I refuse to stay down, quiet and submissive as a woman JUST so that a man's ego and masculinity/balls can be properly coddled. If a man is unable to feel masculine just because we are strong and independent, that's his insecurity issue and has nothing to do with us OR feminism. Gender roles are NEVER good, everyone knows that :S worst post ever
i think that there should be an equal amount of dominence in a relationship, even though sometimes its very hard to find a relationship that is like that and yes a dominate person should be with a more submisve person in order for the relationship to move forward, because two dominate ppl would constantly butt heads and two submissve ppl's relationship would move along very slowly, but one thing that i cannot stand to see is when a woman controls the relationship and makes the man cater to her every need. That is the most annoying thing to me, i have a friend who does that to her fiance and they are only gettin married because she is forcing him to marry her, so her fiance is either going to realize how much he is unhappy and leave her or he going to become an alcoholic.