Monday, 17 August 2009

  • High School/College Relationships - Tell Me Your Experiences

    My boyfriend of 8 months is going to a university about two hours away, and I'm starting my senior year of high school. We've been almost inseparable since we've started dating. This is going to be so hard, it hurts just to think about it.

    We've talked, and we know it's going to suck but he wants to try and I do too. I love him, but I'm so afraid from other posts I've seen that holding on to him his first year of college will only be a bad idea. I know its trust, faith, all that and we have that. We almost never fight. But I think there are factors deeper than that.

    I've only heard advice saying it won't work or how to try to make it work, but what I really need is personal stories. Tell me WHY you or someone you know made it through, or WHY it didn't work.

     

    We learn from history. If it's okay, please give me yours.

Comments (119)

  • SeeBeeWrite@xanga

    Didn't work for me. I was way too attached and he also happened to be a dickhead. He went to an honors college and didn't want to screw it up so he would just ignore my calls for days at a time. We also "talked about it" and he was full of shit.

  • JaydenWolf@xanga

    I stayed with my boyfriend throughout his army training and through high school. He came home on weekends. It was fine.


    We then got married.



    and divorced.

  • Magniloquentia@xanga

    Break-up. One year separation in high school isn't a big deal, nor is one year separation in college a big deal. Despite the closeness in age, you'll be in two different worlds soon. Particularly if he's going to be living in the dorms, life is going to change in a big way. If you stay together, he's going to feel limited, trapped, and held back. It will make him resent the relationship, and maybe even you.


    You guys should break up knowing that you'll be in different worlds soon to avoid ruining what you have now. Some people change immensely when they move off to college, particularly towards the end of their first year. If you break up now, you'll avoid any complications, but still have the lingering emotions that will allow you guys to pick up at a later time, should you both feel inclined. It's for the best.

  • beetunes@xanga

    my ex, who is going to college in september, had a firefighting job all this summer in a variety of other states, so i hardly saw him at all. it was REALLY hard, because we were spending all our free time together before he left.

    he really, really wanted to make it work, so we texted and called each other all the time, but it wasn't the same. and when he WAS in town briefly, i already had plans and couldn't make it to see him. he was really pissed off about that, and he said i couldn't make time for him.

    we broke up. i don't think he was cut out for long-distance relationships. i think i'm independent enough that i would have been fine if he hadn't been so upset about everything i said.

  • sjj1004@xanga

    this is more of a college/post-college relationship, but it's still regarding the same issue.

    i was dating my boyfriend for 2 years by the time we graduated from college in the midwest. i moved to boston for grad school and he moved to chicago for work. it's been over a year of doing long distance, being in two different cities that required a 1.5 hour long flight to get to. yes, it's hard but we both try hard to make it work. there have been lots of mutual visits and lots of phone conversations, to keep involved in each others' lives. who knows what the future looks like for us, but so far, it's been going okay. i think a lot of it has to do with commitment and being able to trust each other... and continually making that other person a priority, even if you can't see them all the time.

    i don't know if your life stage (high school/college) makes things a little different, perhaps in terms of the seriousness of your relationship. but i've definitely know of people who were high school sweethearts, went to colleges on opposite sides of the country, and ended up getting married.

  • bluehoursky@xanga

    It didn't work out, but my situation was a little different [as with any situation].
    My then boyfriend switched to a boarding school which was about, uhm, 45 minutes away.

    Even then, when he came back on the weekends, we didn't really see each other...
    He started ignoring my calls.
    and then one day he just told me that he didn't love me anymore and it didn't feel the same.

    It's a pretty lame story, but I guess it was both our faults or neither our faults.

    I only wish it had ended a little better so we could still be friends now. Oh well...

  • AnonymousBlonde@xanga

    My ex-boyfriend and I were together for almost a year when I started college.  I moved three hours upstate and he stayed home to work.  We saw each other on weekends and during breaks; it really wasn't too bad of a situation since we stayed together through my first and most of my second year of college with minimal problems.

    There's no reason why you two can't stay together and have a relationship that stays strong or becomes stronger despite not being home together.  Just make sure to keep the lines of communication open and remember that trust and hard work are integral to successful relationships.

  • brianbsquared@xanga

    I broke up with my then-girlfriend about a month before I went away to college (granted, the college was about 45 minutes away from where I grew up, but no car meant that it would be nearly impossible to get home to see her every weekend).  We re-connected around Christmas time and I think that the spring semester was one of my most memorable semesters of school.  Again, no car so I didn't see her all the time, but I still went home and made an effort to spend time with her.  Our relationship lasted through the summer before we broke it off for good before the next year started.


    For you guys, if you are willing to put in the work you can make it happen; however, its not easy.

  • xa06@xanga

    "Long distance is a lie teenagers tell each other to get laid the summer before college." - How I Met Your Mother


    Yeah seriously, it didn't work out for me because both of us were way too tempted to cheat while separated. Then again, I guess we both felt too young to get that serious. Hmm.

  • NinjaNikki88@xanga

    I had a boyfriend & a girlfriend from my sophmore year in high school until i went to college. The guy & I broke up that summer after HS but got back together after our freshman year..then her died. The girl & I stayed together my freshman yr but it tore our relationship up. we both ended up cheating and getting pregnant but we still talk today. I would say give each other a chance to enjoy college and see what it has to offer & who you meet. If neither of you meet anyone else then great!..if you do, see where it goes. You cant hold love hostage, give it its freedom and if its meant to be it will.


    Good luck!

  • JennyGee@xanga

    two hours isn't that long

    my high school bf was a year younger than me, and i when i went away (only an hour away) we had been dating for a year and a half and the distance nearly killed us after seeing each other every day.  we held on for one semester and i came home on weekends.  then i dropped out and came home to go to community college.  we dated for two more years, and then broke up for completely unrelated reasons.

    my bff has a long-distance boyfriend who was about 3 hours away for the first two years and is now several states away.  they've been dating for 6 years.  she doesn't recommend it for other people, but loves him more than anything.  they call every day and visit when they can, and they do fun activities like watching the same movie at the same time, and skype.  they're planning to get married eventually, but neither are in any hurry.

    another friend was separated from his gf for a year cuz they got into different med schools.  they talked every day on the phone, and he said he feels like he knows her better now than he would have if they had stayed geographically close because they really just talk- no TV or food or anything else distracting them, just an hour or so on the phone every night.  they're getting married in June

    so, all in all, it can be done   it depends on how serious you both are, how important the "college experience" is to him, what resources you have available to you (like, can you drive to see each other every week or two? have computers to skype?  do parents mind paying HUGE phone bills?), and whether or not you're both on the same page, but you can certainly pull it off if you try

  • t_zie@xanga

    it didnt work 4 me.

    cuz u suk.

  • spidergrass@xanga

    The first relationship I had with a guy in college (before I was in college), we broke up after a few days. He was just too busy adjusting to the college life and meeting new people that he decided we should break up. We had been going out for about 6 months.
    The second one I had didn't work out either, but that was kind of for different reasons. I had been on and off with this guy a lot..when I add it up now, we dated for about 2 years, but that 2 years was split up over a course of 4 years. When he went back to college last year and I was a senior in high school, I broke up with him because I just wasn't feeling it anymore, but I think part of that was because he was away. So being long distance does make a difference, no matter what people say.
    I'm now in my third college-relationship thing, both my current boyfriend and I are starting college shortly. It is going to be hard but I think because I have dealt with long distance twice in the past, hopefully this time I'll be more prepared. I feel like now I understand commitment better.
    Good luck.

  • thaaats_KIM@xanga

    WOW. Last year I had the exact same problem... but it wasn't a problem at all actually, cause we're still together.


    I was in my senior year of high-school and my current bf was starting his first year of post-sec across the country. I lived in Vancouver, while he was in Montreal. I hope you know where those cities are, yay for being Canadian. haha.


    Anyway, the WAIT was really difficult. Every chance we got, we webcammed and phoned each other. Long distance was pretty hard... but we made counting down to the day we got to see each other more fun. Waiting for 4 months seemed like a breeze. Jk, it was a breeze. Fortunately, he decided to move back to Vancouver to continue with his studies here.


    I couldn't live a day without communicating with him... it was weird. But now, I can go for weeks without talking to him. =/ Hmmm.. I don't know. I don't feel the strong connection I used to feel as we were apart. Maybe I enjoyed "antipated" being with him.... anyway... good luck with your soon-to-be-LDR!

  • snapeful@xanga

    I dated a dude who was younger (high school junior) while I was starting my first year of college. My college wasn't 2 hours away, it was more an hour away so I visited him during the weekends. But we were basically "inseparable." This was the most damaging because I wouldn't want to hang out with my other friends when we hung out and I had to study very hard during the times I wasn't seeing him or talking to him because he distracted me A LOT during the school year. We had a lot of issues working it out, becuase he didn't have a car and I would have to always drive to him (I also commuted to school.. so that was a lot of gas to make those trips). We webcammed sometimes but still... blah! 

    My friend, H, she dated a guy who went to a college (they were both first-years from the same college) about 6 hours away. They were inseparable during the summer, but she found out that he cheated on her and never made time for her when he was at school. Didn't work out. He ignored her. 

    Lastly, my friends V and D have made it really work. They had been going out since their junior years in high school and go to schools 2 hours apart from each other. I'm not sure of the details, but they trust each other a lot, and if they do webcam, it's usually just to see each other doing homework (they both go to very prestigious universities with lots of work loads) and it's very, very cute. :) 

    So it really depends how you make it. 

  • el_tC@xanga

    At the time, I had only been dating my bf for about 8 months before we both left for different colleges about 2 1/2 hours away from each other.  That was 9 years ago... we are engaged and getting married soon!  It does happen, but it does take "work" and compromises need to be made.  You never know until you try it.  =)

  • rpghero27@xanga

    My college was 2 hours away.  I left in late 1989, and the Loma Prieta quake struck.  In those pre-internet days, I was just too immature to handle a relationship with my high school gf. 

    Years later, my gf and I hooked up again.  But there's a lot of past baggage, which presents another challenge.  Again, it's up to the individuals to forge a successful, healthy, happy relationship.

  • FIREExATxWILL@xanga

    I was in the EXACT same situation last year. My boyfriend was a year older and we had been dating 8 months when he left for school almost ten hours away. We didn't make it, but it was because our lives were so different. He had new friends, a new school, a new environment, new classes, new everything while I was still stuck repeating the same old for another year. We stopped understanding each other, but mostly what broke us apart was that he stopped trying. All he would ever say was "You don't understand this" and "You don't understand that," and even though I tried to, he didn't care anymore. He didn't want me around anymore because he thought having a high school girlfriend would hold him back. He never wanted to talk because he was "busy" and when we did talk it wasn't about much.

  • proudsmartypants@xanga

    I'm in basically the same situation. T_T


    I'm going to college 14 hours away and he gets to stay at boarding school for another year. And we used to spend nearly every waking hour together and now it's maybe a visit over winter vacation.


    I feel like the odds are against us, I mean reading all these comments about how basically EVERY LDR failed miserably is kinda not comforting...School actually started for him like a week ago and we basically fought 3 times in a week, not great stats I think. And I worry that in two weeks, the fighting will start up again, or even worse, our conversations will be stilted. And stilted conversation seems to be the precursor to all these break-ups, the lack of communication and caring about the other...T_T

  • cassiemaygo@xanga

    why will it work?
    because he loves you.

    why won't it work?
    because he never had enough love.


    you can't take other people's experiences and hope it works like theirs.
    you make your own. everyone is different.

  • UnopenedSuitcases@xanga

    i was going out with a guy for about a year or so, when he started a job in real life while i started college. It was hard especially since I was still growing and learning to find myself. I was young, and I still didn't know what i want. So I wanted to explore myself more. So we broke it off.

  • Honey14

    when i went off to college my boyfriend was still in high school, and the reason it didn't work out was because he wanted to hold me back.  he didn't want me to make new friends, join new groups, or anything like that; he wanted me home as much as possible, and he criticized anything and everything about my school life.  in the end, he was too selfish.  if he had encouraged me to make new friends, and had sincerely wanted me to have a good college experience, we would probably still be together.  going off to college is a big step, and having someone back home who supports you and wants to share it with you as much as they can is amazing.

    adversely, my longest-distance relationship was about 1500 miles away.  we saw each other every few months, and even then, only for a couple days.  occasionally (every 6 months to a year) he got more time off and we'd see each other for a week or two.  we stayed in touch by talking on the phone and texting, and we always kept each other up-to-date with what was happening in our lives.  i wanted him to be happy, and he wanted me to be happy, so we made our relationship a priority.  that relationship was an amazing one, we're still best friends, and we're hoping to be together again when he returns from deployment.

    a lot of people will tell you it can't work, but that's for you and he to decide more than anyone else.

  • revealingimperfections@xanga

    my step brother and his girlfriend were in a similar situation last year. she was starting her senior year, he was going to a college that's about six hours away. they had been together maybe a year at the time, i honestly don't know. maybe more. but they met through doing ROTC in high school, and they had a lot of the same friends. he wasn't allowed to come home except for school-sanctioned breaks (thanksgiving, winter, spring break, etc) because he was a freshman in the corps cadets and that was just how it was, but she was allowed to go visit him. she kind of made it a point to do that. she's friends with a lot of the same people as he is, so maybe that had an impact on the way that they turned out. they had one major fight where they were like "let's just take a break from talking for a few days" but it wasn't like a break up, and they were back on within a week, i think. they've been going strong now for 2 or 3 years and everything is looking good for them. also, she's very close with his family, so maybe that had something to do with it.


    you should be good when he leaves. and if he's not in the corps cadet like scott was, he should be able to come home on a weekend and when he does, make it a point to see him. and also, make it a point to spend time with him before he leaves, and when he leaves as well. try your hardest to. your relationship should be fine, as long as you trust and love each other. and if you both want to make it work, it will.

  • lesprit__descalier@xanga

    wow.. negative comments.


    i'm going into my last year of undergrad at university and my bf is entering med school across the country. we will see each other about 3-4 times until next summer, compared to every single day and every single night we've had for two years. i think if he didn't leave, i might have been sure about marriage in a year.. but this changes things. we will try, but i can predict that it'll be pretty painful. the thing is that the whole perspective of the relationship is changing... our worlds are changing. we are not students together anymore, we don't live in the same city, we don't know the same people, we don't live through the same life routine anymore. the only constant that is left is our affection for one another. but what is this affection built on?


    i think the best piece of advice is, a long distance relationship after such closeness is a test to see whether you were together because it was convenient, or whether you are together because it can't be anyone else..


    it's just another hurdle in a regular relationship. but a really big one. i've been told that distance isn't a good enough reason to break things off. it's just an excuse for breaking up because you wanted to anyways. if it means something, give it a try. if it doens't work, at least you cared enough to put some effort into it.


    good luck.

  • InTheThin@xanga

    I dated my boyfriend for two years before college. We really loved each other, but we decided to break up so we wouldn't end up holding each other back (academically and socially) from our first year at college. Having a SO seems to make people feel more secure and less likely to want to reach out and find many new friends. We went to different colleges, made different friends. I dated one random douche for three weeks before realizing he was two-timing me, and several creeps tried to get together with me, but I never got into any sort of serious relationship. My ex-boyfriend didn't get into any relationships at all.

    After first semester, we started talking again, and it was almost as if we had never started dating. Talking to him made me so happy, and we became "best friends" almost immediately. We'd call everyday, and talk for at least an hour. We really cared about each other, even though we had somewhat lost touch for the first half of our freshman year. He would drive an hour to come see me every other week, and it was just natural that we would start kissing and being intimate like we used to. The friends-with-benefits deal turned into a full-fledged relationship, and we're a happy couple now, about to go into our sophomore year at college.

    Make a choice that's best for you!  Will you hold him back in college? Do you trust him enough not to be a typical college boy at frat parties, inviting lapdances and drunken makeouts? Can your relationship survive the distance?

  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

Who recommended?

Who gave the eProps?

2 eProps from: