Don't ask me, I'm horrible with gifts.

...Victoria's Secret.  He seemed to enjoy it =]

I love making original, homemade stuff. One time for Christmas, I emptied out a big glass jar and layered marshmallows, hot cocoa mix, latte mix, cappuccino mix, irish coffee mix, etc. I decorated the outside of the jar with glitter and ribbons, and tied a big gold ribbon under the cap, and that was the present. =) 

tickets to a show?  (broadway, cirque, etc)  it would be a good gift and a fun date night together.

@xsherryxkimx@xanga - Wow that souns awesome. I don't have such memory to pull that off. =O

Money ?

I agree with the person above, don't make it about something physical, making it a date. Take him out to a nice restaurant (your first date resturant?), a Broadway show, sign you guys both up for a class you like (weekend dancing lesson, photography class, etc.), take him to a concert of a band he likes, take him to a sports event he likes, treat him to a sensual night with lingerie and ask his other fantasies for you to fulfill, drive out and hike somewhere etc.

those types of things he can't buy and have on his own

Memories are priceless.

I hate everything about gift-giving and gift-receiving.  One of the greatest things I learned from being raised in a Christian home came in the form of Gary Chapman's The Five Love Languages.  Basically, Chapman's premise is that all people do not communicate their love in the same language, but communicate their love in five main ways:  Quality time, words of affirmation, gifts, acts of service and physical touch.  Considering you've been with your guy for a year now, you should know which of these (or which two of these) speak the most directly to him. You should do something radiating that kind of love.  :)

If you don't need anything, don't buy anything.  I hate unnecessary consumerism.  "I bought you this watch because I thought maybe you might like it... and I didn't know what else to get you.  But who couldn't use a watch?"  This is the reason I hate my birthday with my extended family, they always buy me useless stuff that I don't want when all I really want is to know that they love me.  Buying me shit that I don't want shows me that they don't know me, not that they love me.  I'd rather they took me out for coffee and spent time talking to me and getting to know me, personally.  So if you have everything you need, why don't you arrange a picnic or something.  Rent a movie he's been dying to see.  Get a hotel room.  Buy a sexy outfit.  Go on vacation.  Be a tourist together in you own town.  Cook him a meal.  Write him a long letter about how great the past year has been.  Make a scavenger hunt. 

You don't have to buy him anything.  Love is more creative than gifts will ever be. 

@DistantStarlight@xanga - Great great great comment, and great ideas.  :)  It's all wonderfullll.  :D

I made him a framed poster-sized collage to hang above our bed. Its not just pictures of us, but notes we've wrote each other and an entire year worth of movie ticket stubs.

Thats just the home-made portion of the present. I also bought him a wii fit, and he got me an iphone.

if he has all of his material needs met...

then why not fulfill one of his sexual fantasies? do something you wouldn't normally do.

or go on a trip! to somewhere neither of you have been before.

I have the same problem with my boyfriend.
I used to be so creative in my past relationship that I've run out of ideas.
But slowly as this relationship develops into something more serious,
I'm becoming more inspired by different ideas.
Because every relationship is different.

My one year passed. And I was thinking of so many things to come up with.
My boyfriend has parents that spoil him, he has everything he needs,
and possibly wants.
As for me, I'm the opposite.
I was never spoiled in my life, except for my long on and off relationship with my ex.
My boyfriend doesn't have a job to get me anything, and I have a job.

So for his birthday/valentine's/6-month/christmas gift I got him a 1TB external hard drive.
Which he loves.
He got me a camera, which I love, since I needed/wanted one.

For our one year anniversary, I still haven't received his gift.
But I gave him mine.
Which was based on creativity and bought with money.

I wanted to do this "12 things of LOVE" like the "12 things of Christmas my true love gave to me"

But not the 12 powered by 12. =P
Just 12 individual gifts.
Each gift representing something significant we've done together each month/a memory.
It doesn't have to be too crazy. I gave him simple gifts.
And I wrote a note on each gift explaining why I got it.

I bought him a handle of Captain Morgan. (Yes Captain Mo is cheap and disgusting)
But we're college students and poor, so it was the only hard A we can afford our 1st year.
And that's basically why I bought it for his gift.
He loves to drink, and Captain Mo was our first alcoholic drink together.
Before we started to date. =)

I guess sentimental things.

Another gift I bought/made him.
I bought a scrap book, but instead of using it as a SCRAP book, I drew on the pages,
and created a story book of how we became official. All the events leading up to the final "Official Status" =)

I also did it because the way we did become official isn't really romantic and would probably most likely be looked down upon... lol so I did my own twists and turns. But he understood what I meant and appreciated it. =P

But in almost all my gifts I always give him a card explaining how I feel for him. =P
I also was going to use my camera to record myself playing the piano and singing a parody song I'd make up but I didn't. I can save that for later. ;)

Good luck to you. =)