Thursday, 14 May 2009

  • What Do You Think of Couples Therapy?

    Do you believe in couples therapy, or do you think it's a waste of time and money?

    Should couples work that hard to keep the relationship working? Should a relationship be hard work?

    Would you go to couples' therapy if you were in a one year relationship? 5-year? 10-year?

    In my opinion, I would probably go if we had kids to minimize the chance of separating and potential ruining the happiness of our kids or if the relationship was more than 5 years old. At that point, I would have thought to be with that person forever, and would try to work it out before calling it  quits.

    What do you think?

Comments (27)

  • Coastie_Lover@xanga

    i believe in going for before you get married. thats what we have thought about doing

  • Angelina_Everlong@xanga

    I think it's a good way to force your feelings out for the other person, to help them understand, and vise versa.  It just helps you talk more openly when somebody is asking you the right questions, ya know?  I've only been to family therapy, but I bet if the relationship counselor is as good as the one I had with my family, it'd be a great idea.

  • KasumiCelesta@xanga

    What? A relationship being hard work? I've never heard of such a thing!!

    ...

    I think it would be a good idea to try. It's one thing if one or both members of an unmarried couple don't feel like fixing the relationship. But I think a married couple having problems really should try. If they loved each other enough to get married, they should love each other enough to do what they can to fix their issues, ESPECIALLY if they have kids.

  • turtletastic

    I think it might be good for couples who aren't really incompatible, but simply have communication issues... Sometimes my boyfriend is really tight lipped when he's upset, but I can imagine if we were paying someone to listen, he'd probably open up without all the prodding, haha.

    It just depends on why they need the therapy, really.

  • pillowpixies@xanga

    A lot of the time, people don't think very well. They don't look at their situations correctly nor do they think clearly in general. An outsiders opinion, a therapists no less, can be helpful if someone thinks a relationship is in danger.

    Now, I'm not saying anyone should run to a relationship therapist. There are some relationships that are simply doomed. If the two people are miserable with each other for reasons that are unfixable, then a relationship therapist would be pointless. However, if they were happy for a while, to only end up miserable over petty things.. a therapist could help them out.

    I think people should work hard to keep their relationships happy. If they don't, that shows that they obviously don't care about their relationship enough to try. If I love someone and they love me, I'd do anything to make it work.

    Relationships will be hard. Whether they're "supposed to be hard" or not is questionable, but they are, and that's all that matters. If someone thinks they're supposed to be easy they're going to be screwed because hey, they aren't. Very few people have easy relationships. Everyone hits bumps.

    And yes, I would consider couples counseling if issues that we couldn't sort out ourselves were to arise.

  • C1NDY_j@xanga

    same goes for me. only if there were kids involved and/or over 5 years.

  • steph

    I'm all for therapy. It's saved my life. If a couple is trying to last more than a few years, it can really be beneficial to have someone mediate conflict so couples can get past it.

  • emra_cadaver@xanga

    i'd go before marriage and during the marriage as well. i strongly believe that a relationship is hard work and will be hard work. i believe counseling can help a relationship and a marriage and i plan do take couples counseling. 

  • BimBo_HiPPo@xanga

    of course it depends if you both are on the same page, both wanting to go down the path of marriage (if its before marriage) because thats mainly the point you need to agree on, once that is agreed i think lots of things fall into place without really going to couple therapy

    after marriage however, i guess i would if we had kids. but what could get sooooo bad that required couple therapy before kids come in the picture?! i dont think couple therapy is really required if you have an open communication line!

  • MuggleLouise@xanga

    Absolutely. I believe that counseling can be a great tool for couples. When two people have trouble communicating with each other, it can be a godsend to have that impartial third party there. That way things don't get twisted and there can be some objective perspective put on things that are said.

    For me, I would love the chance to attend counseling with my husband. He, unfortunately, doesn't want any part of that. I've spent six years of my life with a man who is walking away from me less than a year into our marriage. It sucks. Even more so because I just gave birth to our daughter three weeks ago. I want so badly to fix whatever went wrong between us for her, and for myself and my husband. I don't want to throw in the towel. I don't want to quit.

    The thing that young people don't realize is that marriage is hard. Marriage is work. My husband is twenty-three. I'm twenty-five and obviously vastly more mature than he is. He didn't realize that marriage would be so hard. Suddenly, he's twenty-three years old and he's got a house and a wife and a baby on the way and it wasn't all smiles and sunshine like he thought it would be. Especially during pregnancy. But as hard as marriage is, as much work as it turned out to be, it's worth it to fight for it.

  • mewithoutu77@xanga

    i really don't know what to feel about it, but the other day, i was watching some of the hills episode and speidi went to couples therapy together and i thought it was pretty silly for them to go to couples therapy.  i guess i'm a bit traditional when it comes to that, if it's not working when you're just dating, what makes you think it's going to work when you're married.  it only gets more complicated.  i'm currently rethinking about my current relationship because we're constantly butting heads and if it's not working now, maybe it's not going to work later on too.

  • Ampersands_Anonymous@xanga

    My boyfriend and I plan on doing pre-marital counseling through our church several months before we tie the knot....but he doesn't know that yet. ha!
    But that's a couple years off anyway.

  • MuggleLouise@xanga

    @tvols11@xanga - Probably you should say, "I plan on asking my boyfriend to attend pre-marital counseling with me before we tie the knot." ;)

  • jolisa_betteroffalone

    Idk..my friend is getting married in a week.  They're already going to marriage counseling.  I thought that was kinda weird. 


    but if counseling means maintaining in a happy, healthy relationship longer, then I'm all for it.

  • midge4ever@xanga

    I would do ANYTHING (within my moral lines) to save my marriage.
    marriage is a bond that shouldn't/can't be broken.

  • randaness@xanga

    Of course relationships are going to take work. Believing otherwise is probably the reason people need couples' therapy.

    I don't think people need to have couples' therapy to be in a happy relationship. Some people can figure out how to not dump shit on each other, communicate, and support each other without spending money. I would argue, however, that that isn't most of us.

  • Epinephrine

    I'd say I am not ready or can't find the right one..

  • Forever_Unlimited@xanga

    If a relationship is a constant struggle, it's usually suggestive of an underlying incompatibility. Two people of reasonable intelligence should be able to figure that out for themselves - but then perhaps emotional involvement in their own circumstances might impede their objective capacity to see the situation clearly as they might.

    I think a fundamental flaw is that people characterize their marriage as an obligation and responsibility. They forget that love is also about allure and chemistry, and they surrender their expectations. In essence they surrender all the things that made them passionate about each other, that made their relationship thrive - and that's usually why their marriage fails. Because marriage is a relationship too. It has the same wants and needs. The tragic mistake is in thinking that it's different somehow.

  • ninnatay@xanga

    I'd probably give it a shot. Sometimes people really care about each other but they get into destructive habits with each other. The time to go would be when you realize there's a problem, but before you're ready to walk.
    Relationships ARE hard work.
    On both sides.

  • dreamer_in_my_heart@xanga

    My husband and I were required to do pre-marital counseling to be married by our pastor.  I really didn't like it.  I felt very awkward and felt that it benefited my husband more than myself.  As far as counseling after marriage, I think that if someone truly believes a marriage isn't going to work, or someone really wants out, then counseling isn't something that would benefit them.  If both parties are willing to try and make things work, then maybe counseling would be a good thing.

  • Ampersands_Anonymous@xanga

    @MuggleLouise@xanga - Point taken. There's plenty of time to twist his arm if he doesn't willingly consent at first ;) haha I'm kidding. I'm not like that.

  • objectionnn@xanga

    The only experience I've had with couples therapy was with Heidi and Spencer on the Hills.


    ...


    Nevertheless, I think it's a wonderful idea

  • missleshya

    it is definitely a good area to try...we see how it goes.

  • coconut_dream@xanga

    More often than not, it doesn`t work. Why? Because it`s used as a last resort, when the couple is basically coming to terms with the fact that the marriage can`t be saved.
    Personally, I think couples therapy could be avoided by establishing good communication in the relationship. There would be no need for a third party intervention.

  • anonymous

    My boyfriend and I have a very passive aggresive relationship.  Several times we have decided to end it, just to find our way back to each other again. Things were rocky a little while ago, we both agree that we love each other and want to make it work.  We are trying to live with each other again at the end of the month.  We realize we have trust issue's from the past things we have done to each other.  We are going to our first couple's session tonight.  I'll let you know how it works out.


  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.