Tuesday, 28 April 2009
-
His Mom Forbids Him to See Me So We're Secretly Dating
I've been dating Jay for about a year now and I'm madly in love with him. Despite the fact that he tells me that he loves me, I never feel like he truly does and it bothers me. I think it has to deal with the fact that we have to keep our relationship "secret". Let me first clarify why our relationship is secret:When we first started dating, everything was wonderful, we saw each other almost every day and enjoyed each other's company. His parents were fine with me and my parents were fine with him, but then it got complicated. Jay began slipping in school and staying out late (not with me), and his mom accused me of his actions and therefore forbade him to see me.
Since then it has been rough but my feelings for him have yet to change. Because his mom forbids him to see me, he believes that we should hide our relationship from the rest of the world, and pretend we're nothing more than friends in public, and it honestly bugs me to death. I love him and he loves me. I don't get why we have to hide it. Every time I go to his shows, I get insanely depressed and angered because of how he treats me with his friends around. Whenever I'm there, I don't feel like he wants me there, or even wants to know me. I'm often ignored and acknowledged a few times the entire night and even then, I only feel like a friend to him.
I have already told him about this feeling that I have whenever I go to his shows or somewhere where all his friends are and all he says is, "You know that is how I am."Should I accept the fact that, that is how he is? Or should I feel hurt that I am merely a person in his public life, but this girl he loves in his private life?
Post a Comment
- Back to datingish's Datingish Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in datingish's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)


Recommend


Comments (24)
If he wants to keep you a secret from everyone (excluding your mom, since he has good reason to hide his relationship with you from her), then that's not a great sign. You should be with someone who's proud to be with you. Current boy doesn't seem to fit that criteria.
he's keeping you a secret because he's ashamed, not just cuz his mom. he clearly doesn't love you, and his excuses are just trying to fool you until you catch on. i hope you do, sooner rather than later.
I agree, you want to be with someone who would be proud and privileged to be with you and call you his girlfriend. Especially after a year, regardless of what he's keeping from his mom. His friends aren't his parents. He should treat you like his girlfriend around them.
even if my parents forbid me from dating someone i wouldnt keep it a secret from EVERYONE. especially not my close friends. this doesn't seem right and if he's not willing to change then something should be done. .
@s0rair0@xanga - What she said!
I say get rid of him.
My boyfriend. His ex gf had to hide him from her parents.
& he hated it, and she ended up leaving him anyways.
They were dating for 3 and half years.
& for over a year and a half they had to hide their relationship. Not to mention they lived in two different cities.
Stuff like that gets complicating.
& you're obviously not that important to him.
So dump him
I think he's using his mom as an excuse to keep from telling everybody that you're his girlfriend. Why was he slipping in school? Why didn't he tell his mom that it had nothing to do with you?
I would think that a guy head over heels for you would defend you and possibly even stand up to his mom. And guys usually like to brag about their girlfriends. He can always say "hey, keep it on the DL ... my mom's not supposed to know."
Anyway, if his mom is so against it and he's so weird about it ... it seems like he's not that great of a guy :/
I have no idea where you got the notion he loves you-he clearly does not. Pay attention to what people do, not what they say.
This guy is a liar of the biggest sort-and not just with you. Boys (and I do say boy here because he clearly isn't a man) tend to avoid confrontation. He's trying to dump you without a scene and still keep his options open. Dump him and find someone worthy of you. You've already wasted a year of your life-learn and move on sweetie.My boyfriend and I just broke up after a year of dating.
We stayed together because i loved him and he said he loved me.He recently broke up with me and gave many excuses and kept changing his excuse. He didn't tell anyone that we were dating and insisted on keeping it on the "down-low"I found out that he's been lying to me about alot of things, and he's also been thinking about other girls. My best friend told me that I need to learn and move on.It's hard, and I don't want to but I know it's better that I do.I think you really should do the same.I honestly don't think my ex loved me at all and I really don't think your boyfriend loves you.I know that sucks to hear and i'm not gonna lie, it is hard but there is someone better for you and you need to realize that. No one who truly loves someone else would keep their relationship a secret from everyone, and he shouldn't be shutting you in the dark like that around his friends and at his show. Don't forget him, but learn from it and let go. Move on and i'm sure that special guy is out there looking for you right now.Neither of our parents liked the other, and we weren't even aloud to talk.
Good luck.
I think the whole thing is nonsense. Does his mother talk to his friends? Does she ask them about his relationships? Very doubtful. So if he's only needing to keep you a secret from the mother, why do his friends not know about you? Why doesn't he acknowledge you? It's very hard to believe that he cares about you, let alone loves you, when hearing how he treats you like that.
If he honestly loved you, he would be dying to be around you. He would want all of his friends to know that he was with you, to know how happy he is. He's not doing that though. He's not acknowledging you. He's ignoring you. It's like he's ashamed of you.
You're miserable. Read your own post, read it. You said that you're miserable. You say that it hurts you. You say that you question whether or not he honestly loves you. Are you seriously going to want to stay in a relationship like that for the rest of your life? Really?
If that's honestly the way he is, he wouldn't turn into a different person when it's just you and him. He wouldn't go from ignoring you to kissing you. He wouldn't go from pretending you don't exist to telling you that he loves you. It's obvious that he's putting on a show, and you're falling for it. It's highly doubtful that he cares for you. He may have to hide you from his mom, but he does NOT have to hide you from his friends.
You should feel hurt. He knows you're hurt and he doesn't seem to have any intentions of doing anything about it. Be smart and leave him.
@a_single_raindrop@xanga - Yea, she's got it right.
You're not the girl he loves in private. If he really loved you, he wouldn't treat you that way and he would stand up to his mother. He's just using you.
Love is personal and meant to have private aspects to it, but when you love someone, you should tell others about it. I've always thought of it as one of those things you'd want to scream from a mountain top. He's got it wrong. He's probably scared of something, and you can either ask him what and try to make up, or just dump him. I think he needs to change a lot of things if you're going to stay with him. Right now, he's not cutting it.
If I were in your situation, I'd probably keep it a secret too - cos stuff could spread back to my parents. And if he was slipping a bit in school, I'm sure his mom was just eager to place the blame on you so she wouldn't have to belittle her son (which could maybe even be like belittling herself.)
Still, I think you should be able to tell some people about your relationship - like a few close friends. And he should be doing better in school - so much that his mother would probably allow him to see you again.
But if he's not willing to do anything about the problem, then you may want to cut him loose.
Dump him. He's slipping in school and coming home late because he's been with another girl. His mother has just given him a convenient excuse to play the field.
I'd be mad too :/ . I underestand why you two have to keep it a "secret", but I don't think his mom would be snooping around and asking her son's friends...
You may want to start thinking about leaving him.
TOTALLY been there! My last ex of a year and I bassssically broke up because his mom hated me (b/c she was crazy/racist/control freak).... anyway he insisted on hiding it from his mother similarly
Funnily enough, my current BF has a similar situation when his parents hated me (man!) buuuuut he basically stood up for me. There were repercussions, and it was tough, but I found that if someone TRULY cares about you, then they should defend you, even from their mother's crazy accusations.
Besides I think it highlights a bigger problem (though I can only speak from experience) of a guy not having a real spine if he can't stand up for you if you've done nothing wrong.
Apparently, he don't care about your feelings enough to fix it to make you happy. If he was slipping out on school and staying out late and it has nothing to do with you, he should of stand up for you instead of letting you take the blame for it. Besides, both of you can keep your relationship a secret from his mom but not your friends. If "that's how he is," you need to rethink this relationship. He's not trying to make you feel any better about it either.
I was in your situation when I was in high school, except my parents believed he was the bad influence. Plus, there were issues with him supposedly cheating, which I spent far too much time worrying about. Looking back on the situation now that I'm a few years older, I can say we were definitely too young for that kind of drama. I would suggest you live it up, find someone you can actually enjoy yourself with. Why waste these years with all that drama?
@s0rair0@xanga - Same here, I would do as she did.
Woah! Do not let him treat you like that.
You only need to keep your relationship private to his mother, not his friends, it makes it seem like he wants to be able to attract other females. I don't know, the "secret" relationship sounds rather .. fishy.
no. you shouldn't deal with that shit. dump him -.-
You should be with a guy who will cherish you and be proud to have you as his girlfriend.
Id say give him a chance...If he says he loves you, he probably means it. And its just a phase, dont let ur doubt ruin a relationship.
Once he gets better at school im sure you guys can go public. Just straighten him out first!
I was in a similar situation for about two years. His parents didn't want him dating at all until after college, and so no one could know that we were together for fear his parents or sister would find out. (We're from a small town.) For me it got to the point where I just couldn't deal with the secrets and lies anymore, and being treated like nothing except when we were alone, which was very infrequent because we live 3 hours apart. I gave him an ultimatum, and when he couldn't or wouldn't treat me better, I ended it, even though it was painful because I really did love him. Now I'm with someone knew who is proud of me and shows me every day how much he cares, and I couldn't be happier.
So it's really up to you. Can you deal with it? If it's just going to hurt you and his mom is not going to get over it any time soon, I say find someone better. It's not worth wasting prime years of life on someone who doesn't deserve you. Trust me.
I agree that if he wants to hide you/your relationship from the rest of the world (excluding his mom who he has good reason to), something just isn't right. There's no reason to hide things--if he loves you, he would want to show you off to the world. You should be more careful because something just seems fishy about hiding your relationship from EVERYONE and not acknowledging you in front of his friends...