Wednesday, 15 April 2009

  • My BF Suddenly Decided He Didn't Want A GF Anymore

    After over two years of being together, my boyfriend suddenly decided that he didn't want a girlfriend anymore. One of the few reasons he cited was feeling that our relationship had been going downhill for a while. This came as big news to me, as things were fine during my winter break, he spent a ton of money for my birthday, I came home from college every weekend for a month to be with him, and because he came to visit me at school for three days about two weeks ago.  We haven't been having any problems, we haven't fought or argued in a long while, and it seems that his attitude 180 is what has caused this shift in his thinking about us.

    Within the past week, he's become more and more distant, hasn't been responding to my phone calls as much, and only seems to be comfortable with touching me and me touching him while we're having sex.   When he broke the news about possibly breaking up, I tried to keep my cool and asked him two simple questions for peace of mind - was there someone else? (no) and were we breaking up or just "taking a break"? (he wasn't sure). 

    The only thing I can honestly contribute to his sudden change of heart is his best friend's new college friends.  He's been hanging out with/talking to  them more and began acting weird when they came to visit his hometown. 

    Is it possible that he's doing this to fit in more with his new friends, who I believe are all single?  Does anyone else find it odd that after nearly two and a half years of being together he'd just up and cut his losses for no real reason?  I've tried talking with him about all of this, but he's been extremely tight-lipped (to the point where conversation is nearly impossible).

Comments (73)

  • TruthNeverTold@xanga

    This sounds a lot like many stories I've heard before. It's very likely an excuse to soften the blow, but he probably found someone else. =|

  • Schristian@xanga

    I'm with Truth on this one. It's usually a major sign of wanting out of one relationship and into a new one.

  • addyorable@xanga

    I don't know how to help, but I just wanted to say that this is something most of us fear (including me). "Suddenly" not loving your bf/gf? That's just scary and a little weird.

  • steph

    Well, if you're both at different colleges, it's possible that he just wants to experience other people. College is very much a time to explore opportunities.

    It sucks that he's being like this, but it seems almost inevitable, when people in a relationship are at two different colleges, living two separate lives.

  • MartialArtist322@xanga

    >.< that sucks, you were kinda blind sided. Sorry bout that, but I hate to say it but I think he has a new interest

  • aliasmilo@xanga
  • lovepeacecalm@xanga

    Seriously, this just happened to me. It sucks. I would surround yourself with friends and keep really busy. But as for the "why" of it? I'm still trying to figure that out myself. All the reasons given to me sound like excuses. Only he will give you relief in that aspect, but he may not be willing to communicated with you enough to really know. So all there is is time. Time to heal.

  • asdfghjkieu@xanga

    omg. i was in the EXACT same situation as you.
    my ex all of a sudden said that we're too "different" and that our age is a problem after we've gone out for 2 yrs & 3 months.
    and then he finally admits that "there is someone else" who he's been talking to for week while we're still together. and he said that they have "a lot in common"..total BULL SHIT..she was just as fun as i WAS when we first started dating. they talked about the same shit that we talked about when we first started. and she's not even hot.
    i was so shocked that he even consider her over me...i'm not being a stuck up biitch. i just know that i look better than this college whore because my face doesn't look like a burnt grandma ass. i called her a whore because she flirts with a lot of guys..and my ex was just one of it. she was just using him for attention..she didn't even like him. so leaving me to get treated like this was an insult to me. i was so furious. i wanted to kick her ass and skin her face against the pavement.

    anyways, BREAK UP WITH HIM. don't let him dump you like mine dumped me. his type is not worth it...he's obviously not thinking about your feelings and the 2 yrs that you had together to be treating you that way..go DUMP HIM! don't let him hurt you.

  • AnonymousBlonde@xanga

    @lovepeacecalm@xanga - I'm sorry that you're going through this too.  It does suck, but I guess the only thing we all can do is keep on going.

  • loveconqueredthedarkness@xanga

    college experiences (and the years ppl are in college) change ppl, sometimes into people you don't understand...maybe he just isn't interested in a relationship right now, or doesn't know what he wants, even so...wait it out to see the big picture and let him go on his way...it's obvious he's made up his mind, maybe things will change, maybe they won't..take care of yourself and don't let this get the best of you

  • spanz@xanga

    He probably found another girl. 

  • Schristian@xanga

    @AnonymousBlonde@xanga - It's possible. I wouldn't pass up the possibility of him lying either. Just look for all the signs and see where they lead you. He could just be turning into a royal douche; which isn't AS bad, but still bad.

  • anonymous

    he probably wants to check out the college frat parties, where there might be some cute and easy-going loosey gooseys he wants to break up with you so that he can play guilt-free and not be considered a cheater.

  • Schristian@xanga

    @steph - "Opportunities"? Man, some parents give their kids the craziest names.

  • jeezshoua@xanga

    If everything was all fine and dandy and he just dropped the bomb on you, yes, he probably may had found another love interest on the side.

    I mean, do you really think he would of told you the truth if he was breaking up with you for another girl?  Not really.

  • mynameisblueskye@xanga

    @AnonymousBlonde@xanga - If he didn't want a girlfriend anymore, he should never have wasted his time, when he was with you. Now, if it all kind of went downhill, the best he can do is see what he can do to fix it up.


    I hate to reveal that not wanting a girlfriend doesn't last long. (Believe me. I've tried.)

  • prettyboy78@xanga

    It's one of two things, one he wants to fit in with his friends that are single or two, and far more likely, he has met someone new. Most people when they say no to that question are lying to soften the blow. What would you say if you were in that position? 

  • nsantoro@xanga

    sometimes a relationship that long kind of loses his fire. no offense to you but it could just not be exciting anymore

  • bryangoodrich@xanga

    He probably found someone else and doesn't have the balls to tell you. 

  • chick_fit@xanga

    I say he has found someone else. Your story reminds me of my ex fiance. We were together for almost 4 years, were engaged for a little over a year when he just suddenly decided to dumped me over the phone. He gave me a bunch of reasons at the time but I always feel there's more to the story and it turns out there is..about 6 months after he dumped me..I found out that he got married. 

  • steph
  • pillowpixies@xanga

    Well, really, I do think it's odd that after two years, he suddenly decides that he doesn't want a girlfriend anymore. That's absolutely random, and from what you described - out of the blue. It's as if everything was perfect, and then all of a sudden he wants out.

    If I were you I'd be absolutely determined to find out his reasoning. If he hasn't given it to you yet, there's a small chance that he will; but I'd seriously be interested in finding out why all of a sudden he's not wanting a relationship anymore. I mean, it's affecting you too, after all.

    I don't figure he's doing it to fit in with his friends, really. I mean, he could be doing it so he can be "free" to do whatever he wants, whenever he wants. Maybe he feels chained down by the relationship and wants out of it so that he can hang out with them more. After all, you said that after he befriended them he changed. That could be it. Lately on datingish I've seen all sorts of ways that friends can screw over someones relationship, so there are most likely tons of possibilities there.

    Is he still confused? I mean, really, does he still not know whether he wants it over for good or not? I'm impatient, so I'd end up telling him to choose. Plus, if he wants to stay with you in the end, there's no excuse for him to not explain his reasoning later on. I mean that's really what I'm curious about. (Obviously, I keep bringing it up.)

    I agree with one of the other commenters, this kind of thing is one of the things that everyone is freaked out by. It's weird, it's random, and seemingly for no reason.

    Or, like others have said, he could have somebody else. It IS peculiar that he'd suddenly drop the bomb on you that he wants out. It's also peculiar that he won't tell you the exact reason of why he wants out. If I were you, I'd be demanding answers.

  • The_Tudor_Rose@xanga

    This past summer my boyfriend and I broke up, and right before we got back together he told me he wanted to be a "normal" 20 year old. he didn't feel being in a solid 3 year relationship and ready to settle down at 20 was in that "normal" category. We've dated on and off for almost 7 years. It could be something he needs to do to get out of his system. Let him come around. Being in a dedicated relationship at a young age (sadly I find people still consider 25 young to be in a strong multi year relationship) is scary for guys sometimes.

  • somewherewhereshecansee@xanga

    I've been there. Apparently my sophomore year in high school, there was my friend's ex who really liked me, and he asked me out over MSN, and arrived at my house a half hour later. He was honestly the first guy that I fell for completely. He would just hold me tight before school, kissing me everywhere on my face, walk me to my next class, go on dates, etc.


    Homecoming dance was different. He offered to take me, and he ended up sitting at the table while I hung out with friends, and apparently set some girl (I didn't know that she was a girl, she looked like a boy) to kiss me, and I slapped her for it. I think he saw that and refused to be himself. We went to the car, and he drove me home. He told me that everything was alright, and he wasn't feeling good. Sunday, as I left for work, I read his comment on Myspace that he wanted to break up. We didn't talk for a year.

    On April 4th, I saw him again. He ran up to me and hugged me and started holding my hand. We walked out of the mall (with him holding my hand all the way) to WalMart and then the bowling alley where his mom worked. After he dropped me off, he spoke to me on the phone and then came to my house, to where he said that he wanted us to date again. Sunday, the next day, I didn't see him. Although he still called, he arranged for me to come to his house the next day. Monday afternoon came, and I called him to see if I could hang out with him. No answer. Finally he popped up on the Facebook thingy and he said, "I think I'm moving to Arizona, we can't be together anymore." Which, I found out was a complete lie. I saw him on Friday, he didn't say anything, he wouldn't go near me. From all that drama, I found out that he basically lied to me without telling me straight up. I spoke to one of his friends (my old friend too) and he said that he's with his sort of girlfriend, which he's kind of dating now. So yeah, I basically moved on like he did.



    I'm so sorry to hear about that, two years is a big deal, compared to some other shorter relationships. Was he going through a tough time? If not, losing interest is probably it, and he's probably finding others. I hope that you two work things out for the best.

  • anonymous

    Maybe one of his old friends told him an old flame (maybe even a first love) still likes him.. and he's been thinking about it ever since? *shrugs*

  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

  • anonymish
    • From: anonymish
    • About Me: This post was submitted by a Datingish reader who wanted to remain anonymous. You can submit your own anonymous post at www.datingish.com/submit-post - just make sure you let us know you wouldn't like to have your username displayed!
    Stats: This Week All Time
    Posts: 0 227
    Views: 0 543096
    Comments: 0 13046
    View all posts by anonymish

Who recommended?